by marge piercy from to be of use
being together is knowing
even if what we know
is that we cannot really be together
caught in the teeth of the machinery
of the wrong moments of our lives.
a clear umbilicus
goes out invisibly between,
thread we spin fluid and finer than hair
but strong enough to hang a bridge on.
that bridge will be there
a blacklight rainbow arching out of your skull
whenever you need
whenever you can open your eyes and want
to walk upon it.
nobody can live on a bridge
or plant potatoes
but it is fine for comings and goings,
meetings, partings and long views
and a real connection to someplace else
where you may
in the crazy weathers of struggle
now and again want to be.
Tuesday, December 31, 2019
Monday, December 30, 2019
ONE DAY
by grace paley from fidelity
one day
one of us
will be lost
to the other
this has been
talked about but
lightly turning
away shyness this
business of con-
fronting the
preference for
survival
my mother said the
children are grown we
are both so sick let us
die together my father
replied no no you
will be well he lied
of course i
want you in the world
whether i’m in it or
not your spirit
i probably mean
there is always
something to say in
the end speaking
without breath one
of us will be lost
to the other
Sunday, December 29, 2019
l&c rendezvous
1
what is nearest to me
shadows straining to make
out angles, fixed lines
which hold me cold
and are not what i desire but witness
nonetheless
day to day parades with some measure
of beiges, browns, drumbeat and slight
gestures, pockets of red
windows steam
silence punctuated unlike glass or metal
humid with laughter and sometimes the fear
of being found
2
with winter so close i know
now the ice cream is less
sweet and what compels me to burn
myself remains the same
what compels me to remain
the sweetness
3
if i could just
cup my hands i could just press my chest i could just count your breaths i could just
(sigh)
stay
4
day in i remember the ways you left suddenly
early like stale bread and the door
until i asked another difficult question that again
felt like a small heavy rope
will you stay with
this moment
in the morning
of our lives
11/13/17
what is nearest to me
shadows straining to make
out angles, fixed lines
which hold me cold
and are not what i desire but witness
nonetheless
day to day parades with some measure
of beiges, browns, drumbeat and slight
gestures, pockets of red
windows steam
silence punctuated unlike glass or metal
humid with laughter and sometimes the fear
of being found
2
with winter so close i know
now the ice cream is less
sweet and what compels me to burn
myself remains the same
what compels me to remain
the sweetness
3
if i could just
cup my hands i could just press my chest i could just count your breaths i could just
(sigh)
stay
4
day in i remember the ways you left suddenly
early like stale bread and the door
until i asked another difficult question that again
felt like a small heavy rope
will you stay with
this moment
in the morning
of our lives
11/13/17
Saturday, December 28, 2019
the appeal of reading
from the uncommon reader by alan bennett
"'i read i think,' she said to norman, 'because one has a duty to find out what people are like,' a trite enough remark of which norman took not much notice, feeling himself under no such obligation and reading purely for pleasure, not enlightenment, though part of the pleasure was the enlightenment, he could see that. but duty did not come into it."
"the appeal of reading, she thought, lay in its indifference: there was something undeferring about literature. books did not care who was reading them or whether one read them or not. all readers were equal, herself included. literature, she thought, is a commonwealth; letters a republic."
"'i read i think,' she said to norman, 'because one has a duty to find out what people are like,' a trite enough remark of which norman took not much notice, feeling himself under no such obligation and reading purely for pleasure, not enlightenment, though part of the pleasure was the enlightenment, he could see that. but duty did not come into it."
"the appeal of reading, she thought, lay in its indifference: there was something undeferring about literature. books did not care who was reading them or whether one read them or not. all readers were equal, herself included. literature, she thought, is a commonwealth; letters a republic."
Friday, December 27, 2019
return to madison
by virginia hamilton adair from ants on the melon
it is the autumn of 1936,
my bus from the east coast rumbling
into this place that william ellery called
"the shining city of my manhood's grief."
i wear a ring with seven small diamonds
and a couple more, a little larger.
i am in love with at least two men, also
the trumpet of louis armstrong, poetry,
scholarship, ritual, ice-skating
at 10 below zero, drinking manhattans,
dancing, wisconsin lakes and woods,
being in love with almost everything.
a crisis looms ahead: a june marriage;
but 10 months are too endless to be real.
the other man listens for the phone.
we will be walking in vilas park
before sundown, and that huge feeling
vaster than the continent will rise
within us, unbidden, unforeseen, and i--
unlike the men i love-- never ask
to know what will happen next.
that shining return to a city bounded
by lakes i relive five decades later,
looking up from a stegner novel just begun,
staring into the dusk of a different time zone.
"i knew that the university was at one end
of state street and the state capitol at the other,"
and the exaltation of learning, the sorrow and joy
of that year of marvels pierce me:
one all-night blizzard, and the dawn footprints
leaving from my door, filling with fresh snow.
it is the autumn of 1936,
my bus from the east coast rumbling
into this place that william ellery called
"the shining city of my manhood's grief."
i wear a ring with seven small diamonds
and a couple more, a little larger.
i am in love with at least two men, also
the trumpet of louis armstrong, poetry,
scholarship, ritual, ice-skating
at 10 below zero, drinking manhattans,
dancing, wisconsin lakes and woods,
being in love with almost everything.
a crisis looms ahead: a june marriage;
but 10 months are too endless to be real.
the other man listens for the phone.
we will be walking in vilas park
before sundown, and that huge feeling
vaster than the continent will rise
within us, unbidden, unforeseen, and i--
unlike the men i love-- never ask
to know what will happen next.
that shining return to a city bounded
by lakes i relive five decades later,
looking up from a stegner novel just begun,
staring into the dusk of a different time zone.
"i knew that the university was at one end
of state street and the state capitol at the other,"
and the exaltation of learning, the sorrow and joy
of that year of marvels pierce me:
one all-night blizzard, and the dawn footprints
leaving from my door, filling with fresh snow.
Thursday, December 26, 2019
my life
by billy collins from picnic, lightning
sometimes i see it as a straight line
drawn with a pencil and a ruler
transecting the circle of the world
or as a finger piercing
a smoke ring, casual, inquisitive,
but then the sun will come out
or the phone will ring
and i will cease to wonder
if it is one thing,
a large ball of air and memory,
or many things,
a string of small farming towns,
a dark road winding through them.
let us say it is a field
i have been hoeing every day,
hoeing and singing,
then going to sleep in one of its furrows,
or now that it is more than half over,
a partially open door,
rain dripping from the eaves.
like yours, it could be anything,
a nest with one egg,
a hallway that leads to a thousand rooms-
whatever happens to float into view
when i close my eyes
or look out a window
for more than a few minutes,
so that some days i think
it must be everything and nothing at once.
but this morning, sitting up in bed,
wearing my black sweater and my glasses,
the curtains drawn and the windows up,
i am a lake, my poem is an empty boat,
and my life is the breeze that blows
through the whole scene
stirring everything it touches-
the surface of the water, the limp sail,
even the heavy, leafy trees along the shore.
sometimes i see it as a straight line
drawn with a pencil and a ruler
transecting the circle of the world
or as a finger piercing
a smoke ring, casual, inquisitive,
but then the sun will come out
or the phone will ring
and i will cease to wonder
if it is one thing,
a large ball of air and memory,
or many things,
a string of small farming towns,
a dark road winding through them.
let us say it is a field
i have been hoeing every day,
hoeing and singing,
then going to sleep in one of its furrows,
or now that it is more than half over,
a partially open door,
rain dripping from the eaves.
like yours, it could be anything,
a nest with one egg,
a hallway that leads to a thousand rooms-
whatever happens to float into view
when i close my eyes
or look out a window
for more than a few minutes,
so that some days i think
it must be everything and nothing at once.
but this morning, sitting up in bed,
wearing my black sweater and my glasses,
the curtains drawn and the windows up,
i am a lake, my poem is an empty boat,
and my life is the breeze that blows
through the whole scene
stirring everything it touches-
the surface of the water, the limp sail,
even the heavy, leafy trees along the shore.
Wednesday, December 25, 2019
a formative experience of powerlessness
from transit by rachel cusk
"he had felt for the first time that he was at home: the feeling of having unwittingly caused an irreversible change, of his failure being the force that broke new ground, was, he realised standing there, the deepest and most familiar thing he knew. by failing he created loss, and loss was the threshold to freedom: an awkward and uncomfortable threshold, but the only one he had ever been able to cross; usually, he said, because he was shoved across it as a consequence of the events that had brought him there."
"i said it seemed to me that most marriages worked in the same way that stories are said to do, through the suspension of disbelief. it wasn't, in other words, perfection that sustained them so much as the avoidance of certain realities. i was well aware, i said, that gerard had constituted one such reality at the time those events had occurred. his feelings had to be ridden roughshod over; the story couldn't be constructed otherwise. yet now, i said, when i thought about that time, these discarded elements - everything that had been denied or wilfully forgotten in the service of that narrative - were what increasingly predominated. like the objects i had left in his flat, these discarded things had changed their meanings over the years, and not always in a way that was easy to accept. my own indifference to gerard's suffering, for example, which at the time i had barely considered, had come to seem increasingly criminal to me. the things that i had jettisoned in my pursuit of a new future, now that that future had itself been jettisoned, retained a growing power of accusation, to the extent that i had come to fear that i was being punished in direct proportion to something i hadn't even managed to assess or enumerate. perhaps, i said, it is never clear what should be saved and what destroyed."
"sometimes he almost wished he had never shown her a violin in the first place, which goes to show, he said, that we examine least what has formed us the most, and instead find ourselves driven blindly to re-enact it. maybe it's only in our injuries, he said, that the future can take root."
"at first, his mother accused him of making it all up. and part of him almost believed her: the problem with being honest, he said, is that you're slow to realise that other people can lie."
"when he wrote his book, he said, what he desired was to express himself in a way that was free of shame. one source of that shame was other people's knowledge of him: yet what they knew was not the truth. the truth, he realised, was something he assiduously hid from others. when he wrote his book it was this desire to be free of shame that drove him on. he wrote it in the belief that he was addressing someone who didn't know him at all, and who therefore he didn't have to be embarrassed in front of. that person was effectively himself."
"when i went back to the sitting room i was struck by the sight of jane's jewel-coloured clothing amid the white landscape of dust sheets. she had remained very still, her knees together and her head erect, her pale fingers evenly splayed around the teacup. i found myself wondering who exactly she was: there was a sense of drama about her that seemed to invite only two responses - either to become absorbed or to walk away. yet the prospect of absorption seemed somehow arduous: i recalled her remarks about the draining nature of students and thought how often people betrayed themselves by what they noticed in others."
"what she did learn from all the books was something else, something she hadn't really been expecting, which was that the story of loneliness is much longer than the story of life. in the sense of what most people mean by living, she said. without children or partner, without meaningful family or a home, a day can last an eternity: a life without a story, a life in which there is nothing - no narrative flights, no plot developments, no immersive human dramas - to alleviate the cruelly meticulous passing of time."
"it was perfectly possible to become the prisoner of an artist's vision, i said. like love, i said, being understood creates the fear that you will never be understood again."
"i had been thinking lately about evil, i went on, and was beginning to realise that it was not a product of will but of its opposite, of surrender. it represented the relinquishing of effort, the abandonment of self-discipline in the face of desire."
"that idea - of one's own life as something that had already been dictated - was strangely seductive, until you realised that it reduced other people to the moral status of characters and camouflaged their capacity to destroy. yet the illusion of meaning recurred, much as you tried to resist it: like childhood, i said, which we treat as an explanatory text rather than merely as a formative experience of powerlessness. for a long time, i said, i believed that it was only through absolute passivity that you could learn to see what was really there. but my decision to create a disturbance by renovating my house had awoken a different reality, as though i had disturbed a beast sleeping in its lair. i had started to become, in effect, angry. i had started to desire power, because what i now realised was that other people had had it all along, that what i called fate was merely the reverberation of their will, a tale scripted not by some universal storyteller but by people who would elude justice for as long as their actions were met with resignation rather than outrage.
he was watching me while i spoke, with strange-coloured eyes that reminded me of peat or earth and that now seemed strangely naked, as though by removing his glasses he had also removed the shield of adulthood. i saw that there were plates of food on the table, though i couldn't remember the waiter bringing them. he was struck, he said, by my allusion to anger: it was a biblical word and carried connotations of righteousness, but he had always believed anger to be the most mysterious and dangerous of human qualities, precisely because it had no fixed moral identity."
"he had felt for the first time that he was at home: the feeling of having unwittingly caused an irreversible change, of his failure being the force that broke new ground, was, he realised standing there, the deepest and most familiar thing he knew. by failing he created loss, and loss was the threshold to freedom: an awkward and uncomfortable threshold, but the only one he had ever been able to cross; usually, he said, because he was shoved across it as a consequence of the events that had brought him there."
"i said it seemed to me that most marriages worked in the same way that stories are said to do, through the suspension of disbelief. it wasn't, in other words, perfection that sustained them so much as the avoidance of certain realities. i was well aware, i said, that gerard had constituted one such reality at the time those events had occurred. his feelings had to be ridden roughshod over; the story couldn't be constructed otherwise. yet now, i said, when i thought about that time, these discarded elements - everything that had been denied or wilfully forgotten in the service of that narrative - were what increasingly predominated. like the objects i had left in his flat, these discarded things had changed their meanings over the years, and not always in a way that was easy to accept. my own indifference to gerard's suffering, for example, which at the time i had barely considered, had come to seem increasingly criminal to me. the things that i had jettisoned in my pursuit of a new future, now that that future had itself been jettisoned, retained a growing power of accusation, to the extent that i had come to fear that i was being punished in direct proportion to something i hadn't even managed to assess or enumerate. perhaps, i said, it is never clear what should be saved and what destroyed."
"sometimes he almost wished he had never shown her a violin in the first place, which goes to show, he said, that we examine least what has formed us the most, and instead find ourselves driven blindly to re-enact it. maybe it's only in our injuries, he said, that the future can take root."
"at first, his mother accused him of making it all up. and part of him almost believed her: the problem with being honest, he said, is that you're slow to realise that other people can lie."
"when he wrote his book, he said, what he desired was to express himself in a way that was free of shame. one source of that shame was other people's knowledge of him: yet what they knew was not the truth. the truth, he realised, was something he assiduously hid from others. when he wrote his book it was this desire to be free of shame that drove him on. he wrote it in the belief that he was addressing someone who didn't know him at all, and who therefore he didn't have to be embarrassed in front of. that person was effectively himself."
"when i went back to the sitting room i was struck by the sight of jane's jewel-coloured clothing amid the white landscape of dust sheets. she had remained very still, her knees together and her head erect, her pale fingers evenly splayed around the teacup. i found myself wondering who exactly she was: there was a sense of drama about her that seemed to invite only two responses - either to become absorbed or to walk away. yet the prospect of absorption seemed somehow arduous: i recalled her remarks about the draining nature of students and thought how often people betrayed themselves by what they noticed in others."
"what she did learn from all the books was something else, something she hadn't really been expecting, which was that the story of loneliness is much longer than the story of life. in the sense of what most people mean by living, she said. without children or partner, without meaningful family or a home, a day can last an eternity: a life without a story, a life in which there is nothing - no narrative flights, no plot developments, no immersive human dramas - to alleviate the cruelly meticulous passing of time."
"it was perfectly possible to become the prisoner of an artist's vision, i said. like love, i said, being understood creates the fear that you will never be understood again."
"i had been thinking lately about evil, i went on, and was beginning to realise that it was not a product of will but of its opposite, of surrender. it represented the relinquishing of effort, the abandonment of self-discipline in the face of desire."
"that idea - of one's own life as something that had already been dictated - was strangely seductive, until you realised that it reduced other people to the moral status of characters and camouflaged their capacity to destroy. yet the illusion of meaning recurred, much as you tried to resist it: like childhood, i said, which we treat as an explanatory text rather than merely as a formative experience of powerlessness. for a long time, i said, i believed that it was only through absolute passivity that you could learn to see what was really there. but my decision to create a disturbance by renovating my house had awoken a different reality, as though i had disturbed a beast sleeping in its lair. i had started to become, in effect, angry. i had started to desire power, because what i now realised was that other people had had it all along, that what i called fate was merely the reverberation of their will, a tale scripted not by some universal storyteller but by people who would elude justice for as long as their actions were met with resignation rather than outrage.
he was watching me while i spoke, with strange-coloured eyes that reminded me of peat or earth and that now seemed strangely naked, as though by removing his glasses he had also removed the shield of adulthood. i saw that there were plates of food on the table, though i couldn't remember the waiter bringing them. he was struck, he said, by my allusion to anger: it was a biblical word and carried connotations of righteousness, but he had always believed anger to be the most mysterious and dangerous of human qualities, precisely because it had no fixed moral identity."
Tuesday, December 24, 2019
losing heart
by maggie nelson, from shiner
it feels good
like being
inside a car
in a car
wash, the froth
swopping
the roof, the
windows, a regular
murder of dirt.
but what if
it's the self
at stake, not
crimson with sin
just weary of
its own
contours, the run-on
sentence of its
thought. on
the inside looking
out, a window
streaked with black
effluvia, always
threatening to
become a hunk of
something that
won't budge. when
i was a younger man
it was all about
mozart. then later,
beethoven. then
later still -- mozart!
after that, beethoven!
ah, but mozart. ah,
but beethoven.
you don't really
have to believe in
yourself, only
in your circulation.
it feels good
like being
inside a car
in a car
wash, the froth
swopping
the roof, the
windows, a regular
murder of dirt.
but what if
it's the self
at stake, not
crimson with sin
just weary of
its own
contours, the run-on
sentence of its
thought. on
the inside looking
out, a window
streaked with black
effluvia, always
threatening to
become a hunk of
something that
won't budge. when
i was a younger man
it was all about
mozart. then later,
beethoven. then
later still -- mozart!
after that, beethoven!
ah, but mozart. ah,
but beethoven.
you don't really
have to believe in
yourself, only
in your circulation.
Monday, December 23, 2019
the original choice
from existentialism and human emotions by jean-paul sartre
"certainly, many people believe that when they do something, they themselves are the only ones involved, and when someone says to them, 'what if everyone acted that way?' they shrug their shoulders and answer, 'everyone doesn't act that way.' but really, one should always ask himself, 'what would happen if everybody looked at things that way?' there is no escaping this disturbing thought except by a kind of double-dealing. a man who lies and makes excuses for himself by saying 'not everybody does that,' is someone with an uneasy conscience, because the act of lying implies that a universal value is conferred upon the lie."
"all leaders know this anguish. that doesn't keep them from acting; on the contrary, it is the very condition of their action. for it implies that they envisage a number of possibilities, and when they choose one, they realize that it has value only because it is chosen. we shall see that this kind of anguish, which is the kind that existentialism describes, is explained, in addition, by a direct responsibility to the other men whom it involves. it is not a curtain separating us from action, but is part of action itself."
"on the one hand, an ethics of sympathy, of personal devotion; on the other, a broader ethics, but one whose efficacy was more dubious. he had to choose between the two."
"if values are vague, and if they are always too broad for the concrete and specific case that we are considering, the only thing left for us is to trust our instincts. that's what this young man tried to do; and when i saw him, he said, 'in the end, feeling is what counts. i ought to choose whichever pushes me in one direction."
"the only way to determine the value of this affection is, precisely, to perform an act which confirms and defines it. but, since i require this affection to justify my act, i find myself caught in a vicious circle. on the other hand, gide has well said that a mock feeling and a true feeling are almost indistinguishable."
"dishonesty is obviously a falsehood because it belies the complete freedom of involvement. on the same grounds, i maintain that there is also dishonesty if i choose to state that certain values exist prior to me; it is self-contradictory for me to want them and at the same state that they are imposed on me."
"in wanting freedom we discover that it depends entirely on the freedom of others, and that the freedom of others depends on ours."
"empirical psychoanalysis seeks to determine the complex, the very name of which indicates the polyvalance of all the meanings which are referred back to it. existential psychoanalysis seeks to determine the original choice. this original choice operating in the face of the world and being a choice of position in the world is total like the complex; it is prior to logic like the complex. it is this which decides the attitude of the person when confronted with logic and principles; therefore there can be no possibility of questioning it in conformance to logic. it brings together in a prelogical synthesis the totality of the existent, and as such it is the center of reference for an infinity of polyvalent meanings."
"certainly, many people believe that when they do something, they themselves are the only ones involved, and when someone says to them, 'what if everyone acted that way?' they shrug their shoulders and answer, 'everyone doesn't act that way.' but really, one should always ask himself, 'what would happen if everybody looked at things that way?' there is no escaping this disturbing thought except by a kind of double-dealing. a man who lies and makes excuses for himself by saying 'not everybody does that,' is someone with an uneasy conscience, because the act of lying implies that a universal value is conferred upon the lie."
"all leaders know this anguish. that doesn't keep them from acting; on the contrary, it is the very condition of their action. for it implies that they envisage a number of possibilities, and when they choose one, they realize that it has value only because it is chosen. we shall see that this kind of anguish, which is the kind that existentialism describes, is explained, in addition, by a direct responsibility to the other men whom it involves. it is not a curtain separating us from action, but is part of action itself."
"on the one hand, an ethics of sympathy, of personal devotion; on the other, a broader ethics, but one whose efficacy was more dubious. he had to choose between the two."
"if values are vague, and if they are always too broad for the concrete and specific case that we are considering, the only thing left for us is to trust our instincts. that's what this young man tried to do; and when i saw him, he said, 'in the end, feeling is what counts. i ought to choose whichever pushes me in one direction."
"the only way to determine the value of this affection is, precisely, to perform an act which confirms and defines it. but, since i require this affection to justify my act, i find myself caught in a vicious circle. on the other hand, gide has well said that a mock feeling and a true feeling are almost indistinguishable."
"dishonesty is obviously a falsehood because it belies the complete freedom of involvement. on the same grounds, i maintain that there is also dishonesty if i choose to state that certain values exist prior to me; it is self-contradictory for me to want them and at the same state that they are imposed on me."
"in wanting freedom we discover that it depends entirely on the freedom of others, and that the freedom of others depends on ours."
"empirical psychoanalysis seeks to determine the complex, the very name of which indicates the polyvalance of all the meanings which are referred back to it. existential psychoanalysis seeks to determine the original choice. this original choice operating in the face of the world and being a choice of position in the world is total like the complex; it is prior to logic like the complex. it is this which decides the attitude of the person when confronted with logic and principles; therefore there can be no possibility of questioning it in conformance to logic. it brings together in a prelogical synthesis the totality of the existent, and as such it is the center of reference for an infinity of polyvalent meanings."
Sunday, December 22, 2019
the bus through jonesboro, arkansas
by matthew henriksen
Inanimate intimacy in the plural
Couples under their dark covers
The distance between one body and another
An echo chamber against every stone
The distance between lovers in a rock-lashing wave
The solitude of two together under the waters of night
Or the flattened space between two people on a bus
Talking above the low beams of a few lost trucks
Seeking their destruction or their portion elsewhere
A road imagined as a slick for words in a discrete stream
Flawless enamel the tongue slides along
Or skates off into a future illumined within a highway sign
At the lip of revelation comes denouement or slow torturous sleep
Because traveling does not follow music
Only music brings the body down from the sky
The solid body in its partial form
Inanimate intimacy in the plural
Couples under their dark covers
The distance between one body and another
An echo chamber against every stone
The distance between lovers in a rock-lashing wave
The solitude of two together under the waters of night
Or the flattened space between two people on a bus
Talking above the low beams of a few lost trucks
Seeking their destruction or their portion elsewhere
A road imagined as a slick for words in a discrete stream
Flawless enamel the tongue slides along
Or skates off into a future illumined within a highway sign
At the lip of revelation comes denouement or slow torturous sleep
Because traveling does not follow music
Only music brings the body down from the sky
The solid body in its partial form
Saturday, December 21, 2019
birth hurts
from the three escapes of hannah arendt by ken krimstein
"if we turn eichmann into a demonic monster, we somehow absolve him of his crime, and all of us of our potential crime, the crime of not thinking things through. the sad truth is that most evil is done by people who never make up their minds to be good or evil."
"birth hurts. and instead of tromping along behind heidegger with the solipsistic certainty that life is merely a slog toward death... you showed him, and everyone else, that life is an endless stream of birth. ideas, actions, people, men, women, unpredictable, unique, spontaneous, so much so that the meaning of their actions isn't even comprehensible to the person doing the acting. that everything, everything is about stories, the stories we tell one another about what he did, or she did. because, as you always say, storytelling reveals meaning without committing the error of defining it. but not only stories, you showed that it is essential to forgive, but not forgive and forget, forgive and remember. because forgiveness throws history a curveball. it is, as you say all the time, the only way to reverse the irreversible flow of history."
"if we turn eichmann into a demonic monster, we somehow absolve him of his crime, and all of us of our potential crime, the crime of not thinking things through. the sad truth is that most evil is done by people who never make up their minds to be good or evil."
"birth hurts. and instead of tromping along behind heidegger with the solipsistic certainty that life is merely a slog toward death... you showed him, and everyone else, that life is an endless stream of birth. ideas, actions, people, men, women, unpredictable, unique, spontaneous, so much so that the meaning of their actions isn't even comprehensible to the person doing the acting. that everything, everything is about stories, the stories we tell one another about what he did, or she did. because, as you always say, storytelling reveals meaning without committing the error of defining it. but not only stories, you showed that it is essential to forgive, but not forgive and forget, forgive and remember. because forgiveness throws history a curveball. it is, as you say all the time, the only way to reverse the irreversible flow of history."
Friday, December 20, 2019
burn my life down
from heart berries by terese marie mailhot
"zohar asked my mother if she could sleep next to my bed, on the floor. she listened to me all night. storytelling. what potential there was in being awful. my mindlessness became a gift. i didn't feel compelled to tell any moral tales or ancient ones. i learned how story was always meant to be for indian women: immediate and necessary and fearless, like all good lies."
"in my first writing classes, my professor told me that the human condition was misery. i'm a river widened by misery, and the potency of my language is more than human. it's an indian condition to be proud of survival but reluctant to call it resilience. resilience seems ascribed to a human conditioning in white people.
the indian condition is my grandmother. she was a nursery teacher. there are stories that she brought children to our kitchen, gave them laxatives, and then put newspaper on the ground. she squatted before them and made faces to illustrate how hard they should push. she dewormed children this way, and she learned that in residential school -- where parasites and nuns and priests contaminated generations of our people. . .
i can see grandmother's face in front of those children. her hands felt like rose petals, and he eyes were soft and round like buttons. she liked carnations and canned milk. she had a big heart for us kids. she transcended resilience and actualized what indians weren't taught to know: we are unmovable. time seems measured by grief and anticipatory grief, but i don't think she even measured time."
"you ruined me with touch. it was a different exploitation.
you asked me for my secret. i told you about the son who didn't live with me. i told you that i lock myself in the bathroom to cry when i remember his milk breath. i knew what it felt like to sleep next to him in bed, and he was just gone. i told you i go away.
you said you'd be on the other side of the door. that's how perfect love is at first. solutions are simple, and problems are laid out simply.
i knew that the way i had been living was too complicated for you to see up close. i should have consulted a healer before i went further with you.
our culture is based in the profundity things carry. we're always trying to see the world the way our ancestors did -- we feel less of a relationship to the natural world. there was a time when we dictated our beliefs and told ourselves what was real, or what was wrong or right. there weren't any abstractions. we knew that our language came before the world."
"i learned that any power asks you to dedicate your life to its expansion. things feel continuous when i think of my gifts and heritage. with you, things don't feel right sometimes. i believe you obstruct my healing.
what i notice with you is that i look outside whenever i'm close to a window, and i wonder how many women feel that way. i feel things i would rather feel alone.
things have become more real with you. every time i start to cry, you tell me that you can't keep me from leaving. i feel abject without your passion. i feel uncontrollable with you."
"you will always love me in a shadow. it's not torturous to be with you when i consider being without. instead of feeling the gasping pain of my powerlessness, i straddle it and put your hands on my breasts. i tell you that i'd burn my life down for you.
we try to remember each other this way, and i'm not sure how many times i can do this to you before i forget myself. i want you to will my pain away. i try to think that the things i do to you, i won't ever do harder to someone else."
"you said you love to failure. i made you full and flushed. you loved me until your body failed your will. you said making love was kissing my eyelids. i kept them open once and saw you differently. you rooted against me and forced my eyes closed like little coffins. i wondered how many bitter ghosts it took to create a cold feeling in a room. my face was covered in your sweat. i was all points and sharp corners before i loved you.
you don't appreciate that you've broken me. lovers want to undo their partners. i feel unveiled and more work than you had bargained for. i was unsure of the currency of men and unaware that losing myself would feel so physical."
"men objectify me, to such a degree that they forget i eat. you feed your dog more kindly than you feed me. that's men.
that was also my problem: an inability to distinguish you from other men when i am angry. i'm sorry. if only you could see how little i need in this hospital."
"the group counselor said that one must forgive for one's self and not for the perpetrator. this made little-to-no sense in my mind. we're all on meds here, most of us are half zombie and half antsy: a weird mix. in white culture, forgiveness is synonymous with letting go. in my culture, i believe we carry pain until we can reconcile it through ceremony. pain is not framed like a problem with a solution. i don't even know that white people see transcendence the way we do. i'm not sure that their dichotomies apply to me."
"terri explained self-esteem and its function, and i blame my mother for not saying these things. my mother wasn't big on esteem for herself, let alone trying to foster that in me. i think self-esteem is a white invention to further separate one person from another. it asks people to assess their values and implies people have worth. it seems like identity capitalism."
"she believed in subversion and turning things upside down. she mocked everything. my desire to be normal or sincere made her laugh.
'men will never love you,' she said once. 'they'll use you up, and, when you're bone dry and it's your time to write, you'll be alone without a goddamn typewriter to your name.'. . .
even mom's cynicism was subversive. she often said nothing would work out. she often said that trying was futile and still dedicated her life to other people through social work. when she was unemployed, she rallied for social justice. she did things that required hopefulness. she made a name as an angry indian woman who could consent and disallow things. indian women are usually discouraged from that basic agency."
"the first chapter in your book is titled 'wanting/ not-having.' you and i had a joke between us that i want you back, time and again, because i prefer wanting. even when i am there with you, beneath your breath, i still feel you withholding. it's like your breath -- that i know you've never had a cavity. you lean back and open your mouth. your mouth is so large and unashamed. i feel jealous and amorous when you tell me that.
i am partly sorry for the night i cried in front of you and began to hit myself. you had never seen me do that before. before, i was just temperamental about breakfast. the therapists reiterate that when i'm suicidal nobody is beholden to me. you have the right to walk away. i don't understand, though, why you would look at me the way you did."
"my body left resonance that can't be dismantled or erased. i don't know if men think about what seduction is. it was reading the work you love, and buying clothes, and making polite conversation with your friends -- convincing your mother that i could mother you like she does. it was laying warm towels across my legs before i shaved so that when you touched me, i was soft. it was withholding from you at the right times, and listening to you with my eyes and ears. i worked hard to assert intent on your bed and your body. i've soiled all beds for you with my wanting and preparation. i prepared myself for you as if i wasn't working as a server, going to college, or raising isaiah. the weigh and the dust of me are in every thread of your mattress. love is tactile learning, always, first and foremost."
"because of my medication, i didn't cry over breakfast or minor transgressions. you believed me when i said the past was my fault. i believed me. when you were annoyed with me, i had to prove i was sane. i didn't speak my mind like i used to. you were beaming."
"i couldn't distinguish the symptoms from my heart. it was polarizing to be told there was a diagnosis for the behaviors i felt justified in having. and then, i knew some part of my disease was spiritual or inherited.
i had not stopped wanting to die. it was not romantic because it felt passionless - like a job i hated and needed. romanticism requires bravery and risk. the obsessive thoughts ruined things. good news was met with a numb feeling. the voice i heard was practical. it noted every opportunity to die and then noted how i refused to jump out of a moving car. i refused to take all the pills i could find. i refused to drink myself to death. i refused to cut my pregnant body. i refused to buy a gun. i refused to crash my car. and i refused to jump from a spaghetti interchange. i was aware of every opportunity i missed."
"i'm carrying a child by a man who abandoned me for being too emotional and then got me pregnant. my emotions are unreasonable, you say.
you talk to me like you're teaching rhetoric.
'you're making leaps,' you say. 'there are more pleasant ways of asking what you need from me.'
you carefully explain the semantics of your letter to lillis. you decide for both of us that, given my transgressions, yours pale in comparison.
my language strengthened through all this discourse. . .
you come back to the door to explain how you choose me every day. i only respond with questions.
'then why did you leave me in the hospital? what has changed since then, besides my pregnancy?'
i really want to know, and you can't explain. so, i can't fell safe. i can hear my aunt's voice, telling me that if my security depends on a man's words or action, i've lost sight of my power. i feel like i become worse, the more i know you love me. we are both worse for loving each other, it seems. it can get better. descending to ascend - they call it. everything feels ugly, and we are only at three months' gestation."
"the tips of you fingers feel like wet grapes. i wanted to bite every one. i told you that i needed help, and you asked me to leave. a friend of yours had just taken his own life. it seemed unforgivable that i would be suicidal or wild when you needed me. i know at my worst i appear disposable, or that i make myself that way."
"i went back to get my earrings from your house and saw you holding your laura in the doorway. i still knocked.
you told me to come back later.
how many times did i go back before i got pregnant? when did i become enough for you, and what was the distinction? it would help to know what makes me worthwhile, and what doesn't."
"'i'm not trying to be an asshole,' you say.
'sometimes trying to be the absence of something makes you that very thing.'
i understand i am talking about myself and leaving. we can sit together for hours with the deficit, and it's not unusual anymore - it's ritual. us both, trying to be the absence of something and forgiving each other for the children we have become."
"what do you even want with my sorrow? you are so inefficient with pain -- i realized you never had to cultivate it the way i did. the way indian women do.
you think weakness is a problem. i want to be torn apart by everything.
my people cultivated pain. in the way that god cultivated his garden with the foresight that he could not contain or protect the life within it. humanity was born out of pain.
i learned how to abstain from good things. i didn't expect the best things, and i have turned loss into a fortune -- a personal pleasure. it's not a sustainable joy, i know. i've seen you happy. being close to your joy has been a measured success. i've somehow retained myself, after all of this with you -- retained the ability to revel in loss. this loss has spun and twisted itself into silk my sons will hold to their faces.
i almost killed myself, trying to match your potential joy. it was taking my misery. the thing i am most familiar with. the thing i rove into love. i realized that i could have you and the pain.
pain expanded my heart. pain brought me to you, and our children have blood memories of sorrow and your joy, too. they inherited their share, to cultivate their own children, whose humanity and gentleness will remind them of you and me.
our boys, their compassion to will away inherited sorrow, it's what makes them good and mine and indian.
had i not been born and cultivated in this history, i wonder how dim and dumb my life would be. i feel fortunate with this education, and all these horrors, and you."
"zohar asked my mother if she could sleep next to my bed, on the floor. she listened to me all night. storytelling. what potential there was in being awful. my mindlessness became a gift. i didn't feel compelled to tell any moral tales or ancient ones. i learned how story was always meant to be for indian women: immediate and necessary and fearless, like all good lies."
"in my first writing classes, my professor told me that the human condition was misery. i'm a river widened by misery, and the potency of my language is more than human. it's an indian condition to be proud of survival but reluctant to call it resilience. resilience seems ascribed to a human conditioning in white people.
the indian condition is my grandmother. she was a nursery teacher. there are stories that she brought children to our kitchen, gave them laxatives, and then put newspaper on the ground. she squatted before them and made faces to illustrate how hard they should push. she dewormed children this way, and she learned that in residential school -- where parasites and nuns and priests contaminated generations of our people. . .
i can see grandmother's face in front of those children. her hands felt like rose petals, and he eyes were soft and round like buttons. she liked carnations and canned milk. she had a big heart for us kids. she transcended resilience and actualized what indians weren't taught to know: we are unmovable. time seems measured by grief and anticipatory grief, but i don't think she even measured time."
"you ruined me with touch. it was a different exploitation.
you asked me for my secret. i told you about the son who didn't live with me. i told you that i lock myself in the bathroom to cry when i remember his milk breath. i knew what it felt like to sleep next to him in bed, and he was just gone. i told you i go away.
you said you'd be on the other side of the door. that's how perfect love is at first. solutions are simple, and problems are laid out simply.
i knew that the way i had been living was too complicated for you to see up close. i should have consulted a healer before i went further with you.
our culture is based in the profundity things carry. we're always trying to see the world the way our ancestors did -- we feel less of a relationship to the natural world. there was a time when we dictated our beliefs and told ourselves what was real, or what was wrong or right. there weren't any abstractions. we knew that our language came before the world."
"i learned that any power asks you to dedicate your life to its expansion. things feel continuous when i think of my gifts and heritage. with you, things don't feel right sometimes. i believe you obstruct my healing.
what i notice with you is that i look outside whenever i'm close to a window, and i wonder how many women feel that way. i feel things i would rather feel alone.
things have become more real with you. every time i start to cry, you tell me that you can't keep me from leaving. i feel abject without your passion. i feel uncontrollable with you."
"you will always love me in a shadow. it's not torturous to be with you when i consider being without. instead of feeling the gasping pain of my powerlessness, i straddle it and put your hands on my breasts. i tell you that i'd burn my life down for you.
we try to remember each other this way, and i'm not sure how many times i can do this to you before i forget myself. i want you to will my pain away. i try to think that the things i do to you, i won't ever do harder to someone else."
"you said you love to failure. i made you full and flushed. you loved me until your body failed your will. you said making love was kissing my eyelids. i kept them open once and saw you differently. you rooted against me and forced my eyes closed like little coffins. i wondered how many bitter ghosts it took to create a cold feeling in a room. my face was covered in your sweat. i was all points and sharp corners before i loved you.
you don't appreciate that you've broken me. lovers want to undo their partners. i feel unveiled and more work than you had bargained for. i was unsure of the currency of men and unaware that losing myself would feel so physical."
"men objectify me, to such a degree that they forget i eat. you feed your dog more kindly than you feed me. that's men.
that was also my problem: an inability to distinguish you from other men when i am angry. i'm sorry. if only you could see how little i need in this hospital."
"the group counselor said that one must forgive for one's self and not for the perpetrator. this made little-to-no sense in my mind. we're all on meds here, most of us are half zombie and half antsy: a weird mix. in white culture, forgiveness is synonymous with letting go. in my culture, i believe we carry pain until we can reconcile it through ceremony. pain is not framed like a problem with a solution. i don't even know that white people see transcendence the way we do. i'm not sure that their dichotomies apply to me."
"terri explained self-esteem and its function, and i blame my mother for not saying these things. my mother wasn't big on esteem for herself, let alone trying to foster that in me. i think self-esteem is a white invention to further separate one person from another. it asks people to assess their values and implies people have worth. it seems like identity capitalism."
"she believed in subversion and turning things upside down. she mocked everything. my desire to be normal or sincere made her laugh.
'men will never love you,' she said once. 'they'll use you up, and, when you're bone dry and it's your time to write, you'll be alone without a goddamn typewriter to your name.'. . .
even mom's cynicism was subversive. she often said nothing would work out. she often said that trying was futile and still dedicated her life to other people through social work. when she was unemployed, she rallied for social justice. she did things that required hopefulness. she made a name as an angry indian woman who could consent and disallow things. indian women are usually discouraged from that basic agency."
"the first chapter in your book is titled 'wanting/ not-having.' you and i had a joke between us that i want you back, time and again, because i prefer wanting. even when i am there with you, beneath your breath, i still feel you withholding. it's like your breath -- that i know you've never had a cavity. you lean back and open your mouth. your mouth is so large and unashamed. i feel jealous and amorous when you tell me that.
i am partly sorry for the night i cried in front of you and began to hit myself. you had never seen me do that before. before, i was just temperamental about breakfast. the therapists reiterate that when i'm suicidal nobody is beholden to me. you have the right to walk away. i don't understand, though, why you would look at me the way you did."
"my body left resonance that can't be dismantled or erased. i don't know if men think about what seduction is. it was reading the work you love, and buying clothes, and making polite conversation with your friends -- convincing your mother that i could mother you like she does. it was laying warm towels across my legs before i shaved so that when you touched me, i was soft. it was withholding from you at the right times, and listening to you with my eyes and ears. i worked hard to assert intent on your bed and your body. i've soiled all beds for you with my wanting and preparation. i prepared myself for you as if i wasn't working as a server, going to college, or raising isaiah. the weigh and the dust of me are in every thread of your mattress. love is tactile learning, always, first and foremost."
"because of my medication, i didn't cry over breakfast or minor transgressions. you believed me when i said the past was my fault. i believed me. when you were annoyed with me, i had to prove i was sane. i didn't speak my mind like i used to. you were beaming."
"i couldn't distinguish the symptoms from my heart. it was polarizing to be told there was a diagnosis for the behaviors i felt justified in having. and then, i knew some part of my disease was spiritual or inherited.
i had not stopped wanting to die. it was not romantic because it felt passionless - like a job i hated and needed. romanticism requires bravery and risk. the obsessive thoughts ruined things. good news was met with a numb feeling. the voice i heard was practical. it noted every opportunity to die and then noted how i refused to jump out of a moving car. i refused to take all the pills i could find. i refused to drink myself to death. i refused to cut my pregnant body. i refused to buy a gun. i refused to crash my car. and i refused to jump from a spaghetti interchange. i was aware of every opportunity i missed."
"i'm carrying a child by a man who abandoned me for being too emotional and then got me pregnant. my emotions are unreasonable, you say.
you talk to me like you're teaching rhetoric.
'you're making leaps,' you say. 'there are more pleasant ways of asking what you need from me.'
you carefully explain the semantics of your letter to lillis. you decide for both of us that, given my transgressions, yours pale in comparison.
my language strengthened through all this discourse. . .
you come back to the door to explain how you choose me every day. i only respond with questions.
'then why did you leave me in the hospital? what has changed since then, besides my pregnancy?'
i really want to know, and you can't explain. so, i can't fell safe. i can hear my aunt's voice, telling me that if my security depends on a man's words or action, i've lost sight of my power. i feel like i become worse, the more i know you love me. we are both worse for loving each other, it seems. it can get better. descending to ascend - they call it. everything feels ugly, and we are only at three months' gestation."
"the tips of you fingers feel like wet grapes. i wanted to bite every one. i told you that i needed help, and you asked me to leave. a friend of yours had just taken his own life. it seemed unforgivable that i would be suicidal or wild when you needed me. i know at my worst i appear disposable, or that i make myself that way."
"i went back to get my earrings from your house and saw you holding your laura in the doorway. i still knocked.
you told me to come back later.
how many times did i go back before i got pregnant? when did i become enough for you, and what was the distinction? it would help to know what makes me worthwhile, and what doesn't."
"'i'm not trying to be an asshole,' you say.
'sometimes trying to be the absence of something makes you that very thing.'
i understand i am talking about myself and leaving. we can sit together for hours with the deficit, and it's not unusual anymore - it's ritual. us both, trying to be the absence of something and forgiving each other for the children we have become."
"what do you even want with my sorrow? you are so inefficient with pain -- i realized you never had to cultivate it the way i did. the way indian women do.
you think weakness is a problem. i want to be torn apart by everything.
my people cultivated pain. in the way that god cultivated his garden with the foresight that he could not contain or protect the life within it. humanity was born out of pain.
i learned how to abstain from good things. i didn't expect the best things, and i have turned loss into a fortune -- a personal pleasure. it's not a sustainable joy, i know. i've seen you happy. being close to your joy has been a measured success. i've somehow retained myself, after all of this with you -- retained the ability to revel in loss. this loss has spun and twisted itself into silk my sons will hold to their faces.
i almost killed myself, trying to match your potential joy. it was taking my misery. the thing i am most familiar with. the thing i rove into love. i realized that i could have you and the pain.
pain expanded my heart. pain brought me to you, and our children have blood memories of sorrow and your joy, too. they inherited their share, to cultivate their own children, whose humanity and gentleness will remind them of you and me.
our boys, their compassion to will away inherited sorrow, it's what makes them good and mine and indian.
had i not been born and cultivated in this history, i wonder how dim and dumb my life would be. i feel fortunate with this education, and all these horrors, and you."
Thursday, December 19, 2019
harbor
by maggie nelson, from shiner
not quite at home in the world
and turning toward the terminus
night-swimming with my sister
who stays back by the shore
the force that gets the body
out of the soul
what's person is what you hold
in your hand
a bottle of catsup
the pour of green water
if i were to escape beauty
into the season of giving
i would give to the birds,
the sad, and the leaning.
i would use simple language
to describe the forest. failing that,
i'd find a piano.
nickel body, nickel world
you are a figure illuminated
from behind by a light.
the underbelly of sunset
the rattling of blue logs.
the house is over. that is,
what you never went back for
has been loaded into a dumpster.
a bridge is an arc of green lights
over black water. this is memory
weather, and i remember
the roof in summer. how it stood.
how we stood upon it.
not quite at home in the world
and turning toward the terminus
night-swimming with my sister
who stays back by the shore
the force that gets the body
out of the soul
what's person is what you hold
in your hand
a bottle of catsup
the pour of green water
if i were to escape beauty
into the season of giving
i would give to the birds,
the sad, and the leaning.
i would use simple language
to describe the forest. failing that,
i'd find a piano.
nickel body, nickel world
you are a figure illuminated
from behind by a light.
the underbelly of sunset
the rattling of blue logs.
the house is over. that is,
what you never went back for
has been loaded into a dumpster.
a bridge is an arc of green lights
over black water. this is memory
weather, and i remember
the roof in summer. how it stood.
how we stood upon it.
Wednesday, December 18, 2019
pessimism for mothers
from the emissary by yoko tawada
"in his youth, yoshiro had prided himself on always having an answer ready when someone asked who his favorite composer or designer was, or what kind of wine he preferred. confident in his good taste, he had poured time and money into surrounding himself with things that would show it off. now he no longer felt any need to use taste as the bricks and mortar for a structure called 'individuality.' though shoes were still important, he no longer chose them as a means of asserting his identity."
"one morning yoshiro agreed to meet an editor at a coffee shop, but by the time he'd finished making notes on the project they were to discuss he discovered it was way past the appointed time. when he reached the coffee shop and saw the editor sitting way at the back, shoulders drooping, head down, staring at the translucent skin that had formed on the surface of his milk tea, he wanted to apologize right away but couldn't get to the editor's table. for the whole coffee shop had turned into a parking lot for baby carriages. while babies slept soundly in their mobile beds, mothers talked with furrowed brows. fragments of conversation, phrases like 'recyclable resources,' or 'afraid my son might turn into a bird,' or 'putting profit before public health' floated through the air into his ears. while the women were lost in conversation their coffee grew cold in their cups, the cakes they forgot to order dried up inside glass cases, cracks forming in the icing on top. he caught sight of pessimism for mothers on the cover of a book one of the mothers held in one hand while she had the other thrust deep into her baby's carriage, making circling motions. sticking his neck out like a giraffe, yoshiro saw that the mother's hand was rubbing the head of her fidgety infant, round and round, making a tangled mess of the child's hair. was marika in another coffee shop like this one, reading and talking? having a hen party, or a bull session, was she shooting the breeze or just shooting -- what was she doing, anyway? yoshiro finished talking to his editor and left the coffee shop in a state of distraction. he then noticed that the street, too, was full of baby carriages. while yoshiro had been holed up in his study writing, the whole world had changed. all these children being born, flooding the city with baby carriages, filling the coffee shops with mothers. from beneath their cloth canopies, pacifiers protruding from their mouths like the beaks of birds, their tiny bodies making occasional ripples in their cloth swaddling, the new generation glared resentfully at yoshiro. so this was what a baby is. if he were to meet his daughter amana outside would she, too, look this strange? when the light turned green,, the white lines of the crosswalk disappeared beneath a torrent of baby carriages. there were baby carriages in front of every bookshelf in all the bookstores; in fact, yoshiro wasn't able to reach across the three baby carriages blocking his way to get the newly published paperback in praise of masturbation. still on tiptoe, he looked down into a baby's eyes, unclouded as a mirror, watching him.
not long after that, he heard the phrase 'baby carriage movement' from marika for the first time. this was a movement to encourage mothers to push their baby carriages around town every day as long as the sun was shining. . . pushing a baby carriage was the best way to tell how a town treated its pedestrians. mothers had to stop if there was no sidewalk, or too many steps. where the noise was nerve-racking, or there was too much carbon dioxide in the air, the baby would start howling. with lots of other baby carriages around a sort of domino effect kicked in until the collective howling was as loud as a siren, making passerby stop to think just how unpleasant or even dangerous this place was for human beings."
"'the whole human race is becoming feminized,' asserted some specialists, while others said, 'children who are born male turn into females, while those born female turn into males.'
in areas where culture dictated that female fetuses should be aborted, nature, enraged at humans disrupting her balance this way, had started playing various tricks. one trick was making sure that no one stayed the same sex all their lives. everyone's sex changed either once or twice, and people couldn't tell ahead of time how many times their sex would change."
"all through his childhood and youth, he'd kept his body moving, chasing after balls with his friends, yet he had almost no memory of touch, of his heart beating faster after coming into physical contact with another boy. not only other kids, even his own body had seemed to be moving on some two-dimensional plane like an anime character he could watch but never really touch. the closest thing to a sensual memory he had was of putting his hand into his catcher's mitt, that slight thrill he felt every time his skin touched leather, bringing the mitted hand up to his nose when the others weren't watching to breathe in the earthy aroma. once when a classmate called michiru had left her hand lying on top of her desk, he had touched it by mistake. he'd pulled away immediately, but the shock of feeling her warm, moist flesh stayed, carved into his memory. after that he was always aware of michiru, so much so that even when the classroom faded into black and white boredom, she alone appeared in living color. every time michiru said someone's name he was listening, he examined every letter on all her school papers, watched everything she did at recess. that single touch, apparently, had stolen the key to his heart."
"in his youth, yoshiro had prided himself on always having an answer ready when someone asked who his favorite composer or designer was, or what kind of wine he preferred. confident in his good taste, he had poured time and money into surrounding himself with things that would show it off. now he no longer felt any need to use taste as the bricks and mortar for a structure called 'individuality.' though shoes were still important, he no longer chose them as a means of asserting his identity."
"one morning yoshiro agreed to meet an editor at a coffee shop, but by the time he'd finished making notes on the project they were to discuss he discovered it was way past the appointed time. when he reached the coffee shop and saw the editor sitting way at the back, shoulders drooping, head down, staring at the translucent skin that had formed on the surface of his milk tea, he wanted to apologize right away but couldn't get to the editor's table. for the whole coffee shop had turned into a parking lot for baby carriages. while babies slept soundly in their mobile beds, mothers talked with furrowed brows. fragments of conversation, phrases like 'recyclable resources,' or 'afraid my son might turn into a bird,' or 'putting profit before public health' floated through the air into his ears. while the women were lost in conversation their coffee grew cold in their cups, the cakes they forgot to order dried up inside glass cases, cracks forming in the icing on top. he caught sight of pessimism for mothers on the cover of a book one of the mothers held in one hand while she had the other thrust deep into her baby's carriage, making circling motions. sticking his neck out like a giraffe, yoshiro saw that the mother's hand was rubbing the head of her fidgety infant, round and round, making a tangled mess of the child's hair. was marika in another coffee shop like this one, reading and talking? having a hen party, or a bull session, was she shooting the breeze or just shooting -- what was she doing, anyway? yoshiro finished talking to his editor and left the coffee shop in a state of distraction. he then noticed that the street, too, was full of baby carriages. while yoshiro had been holed up in his study writing, the whole world had changed. all these children being born, flooding the city with baby carriages, filling the coffee shops with mothers. from beneath their cloth canopies, pacifiers protruding from their mouths like the beaks of birds, their tiny bodies making occasional ripples in their cloth swaddling, the new generation glared resentfully at yoshiro. so this was what a baby is. if he were to meet his daughter amana outside would she, too, look this strange? when the light turned green,, the white lines of the crosswalk disappeared beneath a torrent of baby carriages. there were baby carriages in front of every bookshelf in all the bookstores; in fact, yoshiro wasn't able to reach across the three baby carriages blocking his way to get the newly published paperback in praise of masturbation. still on tiptoe, he looked down into a baby's eyes, unclouded as a mirror, watching him.
not long after that, he heard the phrase 'baby carriage movement' from marika for the first time. this was a movement to encourage mothers to push their baby carriages around town every day as long as the sun was shining. . . pushing a baby carriage was the best way to tell how a town treated its pedestrians. mothers had to stop if there was no sidewalk, or too many steps. where the noise was nerve-racking, or there was too much carbon dioxide in the air, the baby would start howling. with lots of other baby carriages around a sort of domino effect kicked in until the collective howling was as loud as a siren, making passerby stop to think just how unpleasant or even dangerous this place was for human beings."
"'the whole human race is becoming feminized,' asserted some specialists, while others said, 'children who are born male turn into females, while those born female turn into males.'
in areas where culture dictated that female fetuses should be aborted, nature, enraged at humans disrupting her balance this way, had started playing various tricks. one trick was making sure that no one stayed the same sex all their lives. everyone's sex changed either once or twice, and people couldn't tell ahead of time how many times their sex would change."
"all through his childhood and youth, he'd kept his body moving, chasing after balls with his friends, yet he had almost no memory of touch, of his heart beating faster after coming into physical contact with another boy. not only other kids, even his own body had seemed to be moving on some two-dimensional plane like an anime character he could watch but never really touch. the closest thing to a sensual memory he had was of putting his hand into his catcher's mitt, that slight thrill he felt every time his skin touched leather, bringing the mitted hand up to his nose when the others weren't watching to breathe in the earthy aroma. once when a classmate called michiru had left her hand lying on top of her desk, he had touched it by mistake. he'd pulled away immediately, but the shock of feeling her warm, moist flesh stayed, carved into his memory. after that he was always aware of michiru, so much so that even when the classroom faded into black and white boredom, she alone appeared in living color. every time michiru said someone's name he was listening, he examined every letter on all her school papers, watched everything she did at recess. that single touch, apparently, had stolen the key to his heart."
Tuesday, December 17, 2019
forgetfulness
by billy collins from sailing alone around the room
the name of the author is the first to go
followed obediently by the title, the plot,
the heartbreaking conclusion, the entire novel
which suddenly becomes ones you have never read, never even heard of,
as if, one by one, the memories you used to harbor
decided to retire to the southern hemisphere of the brain,
to a little fishing village where there are no phones.
long ago you kissed the names of the nine muses good-bye
and watched the quadratic equation pack its bag,
and even now as you memorize the order of the planets,
something else is slipping away, a state flower perhaps,
the address of an uncle, the capital of paraguay.
whatever it is you are struggling to remember
it is not poised on the tip of your tongue,
not even lurking in some obscure corner of your spleen.
it has floated away down a dark mythological river
whose name begins with an L as far as you can recall,
well on your own way to oblivion where you will join those
who have even forgotten how to swim and how to ride a bicycle.
no wonder you rise in the middle of the night
to look up the date of a famous battle in a book on war.
no wonder the moon in the window seems to have drifted
out of a love poem that you used to know by heart.
the name of the author is the first to go
followed obediently by the title, the plot,
the heartbreaking conclusion, the entire novel
which suddenly becomes ones you have never read, never even heard of,
as if, one by one, the memories you used to harbor
decided to retire to the southern hemisphere of the brain,
to a little fishing village where there are no phones.
long ago you kissed the names of the nine muses good-bye
and watched the quadratic equation pack its bag,
and even now as you memorize the order of the planets,
something else is slipping away, a state flower perhaps,
the address of an uncle, the capital of paraguay.
whatever it is you are struggling to remember
it is not poised on the tip of your tongue,
not even lurking in some obscure corner of your spleen.
it has floated away down a dark mythological river
whose name begins with an L as far as you can recall,
well on your own way to oblivion where you will join those
who have even forgotten how to swim and how to ride a bicycle.
no wonder you rise in the middle of the night
to look up the date of a famous battle in a book on war.
no wonder the moon in the window seems to have drifted
out of a love poem that you used to know by heart.
Monday, December 16, 2019
the physical reality
from family life by akhil sharma
"it is also hard to remember how frugal we were. we saved the cotton that comes inside pill bottles. our mothers used it to make wicks. this frugality meant that we were sensitive to the physical reality of our world in a way most people no longer are. when my mother bought a box of matches, she had my brother sit at a table and use a razor to split the matches in half. when we had to light several things, we would use the match to set a twist of paper on fire and then walk around the apartment lighting the stove, the incense stick, the mosquito coil. this close engagement with things meant that we were conscious that the wood of a match is soft, that a bit of spit on paper slows down how it burns."
"it is also hard to remember how frugal we were. we saved the cotton that comes inside pill bottles. our mothers used it to make wicks. this frugality meant that we were sensitive to the physical reality of our world in a way most people no longer are. when my mother bought a box of matches, she had my brother sit at a table and use a razor to split the matches in half. when we had to light several things, we would use the match to set a twist of paper on fire and then walk around the apartment lighting the stove, the incense stick, the mosquito coil. this close engagement with things meant that we were conscious that the wood of a match is soft, that a bit of spit on paper slows down how it burns."
Sunday, December 15, 2019
generosity & dignity
from beyond religion by the dalai lama
"a key element in biased feelings is what we can call 'attachment.' once, at a scientific conference in argentina, a mentor of my friend francisco varela told me that, as a scientist, he should not be too attached to his own field of research, as this might distort his ability to assess evidence objectively. hearing these words, i immediately felt they should also apply to the religious domain. for example, as a buddhist, i should strive not to develop excessive attachment toward buddhism. for to do so would hinder my ability to see the value of other faith traditions.
furthermore, when there is an element of attachment, our affection and concern for others are often dependent on the way those others relate to us. we feel concern for those who care for us and treat us well. but when our affection is dependent on the fulfillment of our own goals and expectations, which we project onto others, it will always be very fragile. so long as the others meet our expectations, everything is fine, but as soon as they do not, our feelings of affection can easily turn to resentment and even hatred."
"furthermore, although compassion arises from empathy, the two are not the same. empathy is characterized by a kind of emotional resonance -- feeling with the other person. compassion, in contrast, is not just sharing experience with others, but also wishing to see them relieved of their suffering. being compassionate does not mean remaining entirely at the level of feeling, which could be quite draining. after all, compassionate doctors would not be very effective if they were always preoccupied with sharing their patients' pain. compassion means wanting to do something to relieve the hardships of others, and this desire to help, far from dragging us further into suffering ourselves, actually gives us energy and a sense of purpose and direction. when we act upon this motivation, both we and those around us benefit still more."
"for many, it seems, there is a conflict between the principle of compassion, which implies forgiveness, and the exercise of justice, which requires punishment for wrongdoing. as they see it, the principle of justice or fairness, rather than that of compassion, must underpin any humanistic approach to ethics. to give priority to compassion and forgiveness, they argue, would allow perpetrators of harm to go unpunished and hand victory to the aggressors. the ethic of compassion, they say, amounts to little more than an ethic of victimhood, under which aggression always triumphs, wrongdoing is always forgiven, and the weak are defenseless.
this objection rests, in my view, on a fundamental misunderstanding of what compassion entails in practice. nothing in the principle of compassion - the wish to see others relieved of suffering - involves surrendering to the misdeeds of others. nor does compassion demand that we meekly accept injustice. far from promoting weakness or passivity, compassion requires great fortitude and strength of character."
"compassion demands that we condemn wrong actions and oppose them with all means necessary, while at the same time forgiving and maintaining an attitude of kindness toward the perpetrators of those actions."
"a key element in biased feelings is what we can call 'attachment.' once, at a scientific conference in argentina, a mentor of my friend francisco varela told me that, as a scientist, he should not be too attached to his own field of research, as this might distort his ability to assess evidence objectively. hearing these words, i immediately felt they should also apply to the religious domain. for example, as a buddhist, i should strive not to develop excessive attachment toward buddhism. for to do so would hinder my ability to see the value of other faith traditions.
furthermore, when there is an element of attachment, our affection and concern for others are often dependent on the way those others relate to us. we feel concern for those who care for us and treat us well. but when our affection is dependent on the fulfillment of our own goals and expectations, which we project onto others, it will always be very fragile. so long as the others meet our expectations, everything is fine, but as soon as they do not, our feelings of affection can easily turn to resentment and even hatred."
"furthermore, although compassion arises from empathy, the two are not the same. empathy is characterized by a kind of emotional resonance -- feeling with the other person. compassion, in contrast, is not just sharing experience with others, but also wishing to see them relieved of their suffering. being compassionate does not mean remaining entirely at the level of feeling, which could be quite draining. after all, compassionate doctors would not be very effective if they were always preoccupied with sharing their patients' pain. compassion means wanting to do something to relieve the hardships of others, and this desire to help, far from dragging us further into suffering ourselves, actually gives us energy and a sense of purpose and direction. when we act upon this motivation, both we and those around us benefit still more."
"for many, it seems, there is a conflict between the principle of compassion, which implies forgiveness, and the exercise of justice, which requires punishment for wrongdoing. as they see it, the principle of justice or fairness, rather than that of compassion, must underpin any humanistic approach to ethics. to give priority to compassion and forgiveness, they argue, would allow perpetrators of harm to go unpunished and hand victory to the aggressors. the ethic of compassion, they say, amounts to little more than an ethic of victimhood, under which aggression always triumphs, wrongdoing is always forgiven, and the weak are defenseless.
this objection rests, in my view, on a fundamental misunderstanding of what compassion entails in practice. nothing in the principle of compassion - the wish to see others relieved of suffering - involves surrendering to the misdeeds of others. nor does compassion demand that we meekly accept injustice. far from promoting weakness or passivity, compassion requires great fortitude and strength of character."
"compassion demands that we condemn wrong actions and oppose them with all means necessary, while at the same time forgiving and maintaining an attitude of kindness toward the perpetrators of those actions."
"an austrian economist named ernst fehr introduced an interesting concept that he calls 'altruistic punishment.' he illustrated the concept by means of a game of trust. the game is played in rounds and involves ten players. the players are given equal amounts of money and asked to contribute some of it to a collective fund. the experimenter explains that in each round the total amount the players contribute to this fund will be doubled and then redistributed equally among them. in the early rounds, most players are quite generous, making substantial contributions to the central fund, in the belief that others will do the same. this, i think, reflects the intuitively optimistic side of human nature. inevitably, however, there are some individuals who hold back and contribute nothing. in basic monetary terms, they see that what profits them most is to keep their share of what is given, without spending any money of their own. such people, i understand, are known in the language of economics as 'free riders.' as a result of their behavior, the other players start to feel they are being taken advantage of, and begin to contribute less and less to the central fund until finally, usually by about the tenth round, the entire system breaks down. at this stage, no one is willing to contribute, even though the experimenter's offer to double any money contributed is still in place.
at this point the players are introduced to the notion of altruistic punishment, a mechanism by which they can punish the free riders. by contributing some of their own money to a nonrefundable punishment bin, they are able to force free riders to pay double that amount. so, for example, by spending three dollars on punishment, a player can make the free rider pay six dollars. as it turns out, once this system is introduced into the game, cooperation between players can be sustained more of less indefinitely. would-be free riders are deterred from taking advantage of others, and as a result the players continue to contribute to the central fund and everyone benefits.
although this experiment was principally designed to test a theory in economics, i feel that it also contains a universally applicable message. it shows us that punishment can be exacted in a way that benefits everyone, including wrongdoers themselves. it illustrates the point that punishment which does not exact revenge, but rather corrects the wrongdoer, is in everyone’s interest.”
"in moments of anger or irritation, we may be rude to loved ones or aggressive toward others. later we may feel some remorse or regret, but when looking back on our outburst, we do not fail to distinguish between what we did and who we are. we naturally forgive ourselves and perhaps resolve not to do the same thing again. given that we find it so easy to forgive ourselves, surely we can extend the same courtesy to others! of course not everyone is able to forgive [themself], and this can be an obstacle. for such people, it may be important to practice compassion and forgiveness towards themselves, as the foundation for practicing compassion and forgiveness toward others."
"practicing awareness is not quite the same as listening to your conscience, however. in buddhist ethical theory there is no idea of the conscience as a distinct mental faculty. but being conscientious is still very important. it is described in terms of two key mental mental qualities, namely self-respect and consideration of others.
the first of these, self-respect, relates to having a sense of personal integrity, a self-image as a person who upholds certain values. so when we are tempted to indulge in harmful behavior, our self-image acts as a restraint, as we think 'this is unbecoming of me.' the second mental quality, consideration of others, pertains to having a healthy regard for others' opinions, especially for their potential disapproval. together, these two factors give us an added level of caution about doing wrong which can strengthen our moral compass."
"in the context of secular ethics, perhaps the antidote to destructive emotion with the most urgent and immediate relevance for our everyday lives is what is called soe pa in tibetan. though usually translated as patience, soe pa also includes the virtues of tolerance, forbearance, and forgiveness. what it really means is the ability to endure suffering. it entails not giving in to our instinctive urge to respond negatively to our difficulties. but soe pa has nothing to do with being either passive or impotent. it is not a case of tolerating something just because you do not have the ability to hit back. nor is it enduring injustice grudgingly, through gritted teeth. instead, genuine patience requires great strength. it is fundamentally the exercise of restraint based on mental discipline. there are three aspects of patience, or forbearance, to consider: forbearance toward those who harm us, acceptance of suffering, and acceptance of reality."
"the only effective antidote to greed is moderation and contentment.
of course, in extolling the benefits of simplicity and modesty, i am not suggesting that poverty is acceptable. on the contrary, poverty is a tremendous hardship, one that we must do all we can to end. in addition to making survival a struggle, poverty tends to disempower people and make them feel cowed or demoralized. in these ways, it makes the poor suffer greatly. on the personal level, however, the sooner we accept that riches alone do not bring happiness, and the sooner we learn to live with a sense of modesty, the better off we will be, especially with respect to our happiness.
time and geography will always impose limits on how much wealth anyone can succeed in accruing in a single lifetime. given this natural limit, it seems wiser to set one's own limits through the exercise of contentment. in contrast, when it comes to acquiring mental riches, the potential is limitless. here, where there is no natural limit, it is appropriate not to be contented with what you have, but to constantly strive for more. unfortunately, most of us do the exact opposite. we are never quite satisfied with what we have materially, but we tend to be thoroughly complacent about our mental riches."
"it is useful to begin by reflecting on the harm we do to ourselves, even physically, when we succumb to temptation and bad habits. then we can also consider the harm that our bad habits inflict on others. it is easy to assume that our personal behavior and habits have no real effect on others, but this is seldom the case. suppose, for example, that one member of a family is addicted to drugs. although, of course, the other family members will not suffer the direct physical and mental ill effects of the drug, this does not mean they will not be harmed. in all likelihood they will be deeply afflicted by worry and concern, as well as by whatever other agonies and complications may accompany the situation. so, when considering the harm we inflict through a lack of self-discipline in our personal habits, we should always be mindful of those who care about our welfare and those whose welfare is intimately connected to our own.
it can also be useful to consider the harmful effects of a lack of self-discipline at a wider social level. in my view the problem of corruption, which is prevalent in so many parts of the world, is actually nothing but a failure of self-discipline. corruption is always a surrender to self-serving attitudes of greed, bias, and dishonesty. even the existence of a fair and just legal system becomes of little value when that system is paralyzed by corruption.
with the awareness that comes from contemplating the consequences of a lack of self-discipline, we can gradually develop a greater ability to resist temptation in our own life. eventually, with sustained practice, self-discipline will start to come naturally and will no longer require conscious effort and willpower. at that point, when restraint and moderation come naturally, we begin to feel the great sense of freedom that comes with self-mastery. this virtue of self-discipline is extolled in all the world's major religious traditions. . .
gaining mastery over our destructive propensities through the exercise of awareness and self-discipline at the levels of body, speech, and mind frees us from the inner turmoil that naturally arises when our behavior is at odds with our ideals. in place of this turmoil come confidence, integrity, and dignity"
"classical buddhist texts describe generosity in terms of four kinds of giving: first, the giving of material goods; second, the giving of freedom from fear, which means offering safety and security to others and dealing with them honestly; third, the giving of spiritual counsel, which entails offering comfort, concern, and advice to support others' psychological and emotional well-being; and fourth, the giving of love.
an important point to recognize at the outset is that the aim of any of these four kinds of giving should never be to ingratiate oneself with others, but should always be to benefit the recipient. if one's motivation is in any way connected to seeking one's own benefit, this is not genuine generosity.
classical buddhist texts also note the need to be discerning when engaging in acts of generosity. for example, in addition to ensuring the soundness of one's motivation, they discuss the need to be aware of specific contexts in which giving might not be appropriate. giving disproportionately, or giving to someone at a wrong time, might do the recipient more harm than good. and clearly there are certain items, such as poisons or weapons, which are, by their very nature, inappropriate for giving. if what we give is likely to be used to harm others, the principle of compassion dictates that we shun giving in that context. furthermore, these texts emphasize the need to be sure we are giving out of respect for the recipient, not out of a sense of superiority. a genuine act of generosity will honor the recipient's dignity."
"in moments of anger or irritation, we may be rude to loved ones or aggressive toward others. later we may feel some remorse or regret, but when looking back on our outburst, we do not fail to distinguish between what we did and who we are. we naturally forgive ourselves and perhaps resolve not to do the same thing again. given that we find it so easy to forgive ourselves, surely we can extend the same courtesy to others! of course not everyone is able to forgive [themself], and this can be an obstacle. for such people, it may be important to practice compassion and forgiveness towards themselves, as the foundation for practicing compassion and forgiveness toward others."
"practicing awareness is not quite the same as listening to your conscience, however. in buddhist ethical theory there is no idea of the conscience as a distinct mental faculty. but being conscientious is still very important. it is described in terms of two key mental mental qualities, namely self-respect and consideration of others.
the first of these, self-respect, relates to having a sense of personal integrity, a self-image as a person who upholds certain values. so when we are tempted to indulge in harmful behavior, our self-image acts as a restraint, as we think 'this is unbecoming of me.' the second mental quality, consideration of others, pertains to having a healthy regard for others' opinions, especially for their potential disapproval. together, these two factors give us an added level of caution about doing wrong which can strengthen our moral compass."
"in the context of secular ethics, perhaps the antidote to destructive emotion with the most urgent and immediate relevance for our everyday lives is what is called soe pa in tibetan. though usually translated as patience, soe pa also includes the virtues of tolerance, forbearance, and forgiveness. what it really means is the ability to endure suffering. it entails not giving in to our instinctive urge to respond negatively to our difficulties. but soe pa has nothing to do with being either passive or impotent. it is not a case of tolerating something just because you do not have the ability to hit back. nor is it enduring injustice grudgingly, through gritted teeth. instead, genuine patience requires great strength. it is fundamentally the exercise of restraint based on mental discipline. there are three aspects of patience, or forbearance, to consider: forbearance toward those who harm us, acceptance of suffering, and acceptance of reality."
"the only effective antidote to greed is moderation and contentment.
of course, in extolling the benefits of simplicity and modesty, i am not suggesting that poverty is acceptable. on the contrary, poverty is a tremendous hardship, one that we must do all we can to end. in addition to making survival a struggle, poverty tends to disempower people and make them feel cowed or demoralized. in these ways, it makes the poor suffer greatly. on the personal level, however, the sooner we accept that riches alone do not bring happiness, and the sooner we learn to live with a sense of modesty, the better off we will be, especially with respect to our happiness.
time and geography will always impose limits on how much wealth anyone can succeed in accruing in a single lifetime. given this natural limit, it seems wiser to set one's own limits through the exercise of contentment. in contrast, when it comes to acquiring mental riches, the potential is limitless. here, where there is no natural limit, it is appropriate not to be contented with what you have, but to constantly strive for more. unfortunately, most of us do the exact opposite. we are never quite satisfied with what we have materially, but we tend to be thoroughly complacent about our mental riches."
"it is useful to begin by reflecting on the harm we do to ourselves, even physically, when we succumb to temptation and bad habits. then we can also consider the harm that our bad habits inflict on others. it is easy to assume that our personal behavior and habits have no real effect on others, but this is seldom the case. suppose, for example, that one member of a family is addicted to drugs. although, of course, the other family members will not suffer the direct physical and mental ill effects of the drug, this does not mean they will not be harmed. in all likelihood they will be deeply afflicted by worry and concern, as well as by whatever other agonies and complications may accompany the situation. so, when considering the harm we inflict through a lack of self-discipline in our personal habits, we should always be mindful of those who care about our welfare and those whose welfare is intimately connected to our own.
it can also be useful to consider the harmful effects of a lack of self-discipline at a wider social level. in my view the problem of corruption, which is prevalent in so many parts of the world, is actually nothing but a failure of self-discipline. corruption is always a surrender to self-serving attitudes of greed, bias, and dishonesty. even the existence of a fair and just legal system becomes of little value when that system is paralyzed by corruption.
with the awareness that comes from contemplating the consequences of a lack of self-discipline, we can gradually develop a greater ability to resist temptation in our own life. eventually, with sustained practice, self-discipline will start to come naturally and will no longer require conscious effort and willpower. at that point, when restraint and moderation come naturally, we begin to feel the great sense of freedom that comes with self-mastery. this virtue of self-discipline is extolled in all the world's major religious traditions. . .
gaining mastery over our destructive propensities through the exercise of awareness and self-discipline at the levels of body, speech, and mind frees us from the inner turmoil that naturally arises when our behavior is at odds with our ideals. in place of this turmoil come confidence, integrity, and dignity"
"classical buddhist texts describe generosity in terms of four kinds of giving: first, the giving of material goods; second, the giving of freedom from fear, which means offering safety and security to others and dealing with them honestly; third, the giving of spiritual counsel, which entails offering comfort, concern, and advice to support others' psychological and emotional well-being; and fourth, the giving of love.
an important point to recognize at the outset is that the aim of any of these four kinds of giving should never be to ingratiate oneself with others, but should always be to benefit the recipient. if one's motivation is in any way connected to seeking one's own benefit, this is not genuine generosity.
classical buddhist texts also note the need to be discerning when engaging in acts of generosity. for example, in addition to ensuring the soundness of one's motivation, they discuss the need to be aware of specific contexts in which giving might not be appropriate. giving disproportionately, or giving to someone at a wrong time, might do the recipient more harm than good. and clearly there are certain items, such as poisons or weapons, which are, by their very nature, inappropriate for giving. if what we give is likely to be used to harm others, the principle of compassion dictates that we shun giving in that context. furthermore, these texts emphasize the need to be sure we are giving out of respect for the recipient, not out of a sense of superiority. a genuine act of generosity will honor the recipient's dignity."
Saturday, December 14, 2019
twelve points
excerpt from the drama of the gifted child by alice miller
For some years now, there has been proof that the devastating effects of the traumatization of children take their inevitable toll on society – a fact that we are still forbidden to recognize. This knowledge concerns every single one of us and – if disseminated widely enough – should lead to fundamental changes in society; above all, to a halt in the blind escalation of violence. The following points are intended to amplify my meaning:
- All children are born to grow, to develop, to live, to love, and to articulate their needs and feelings for their self-protection.
- For their development, children need the respect and protection of adults who take them seriously, love them, and honestly help them to become oriented in the world.
- When these vital needs are frustrated and children are, instead, abused for the sake of adults’ needs by being exploited, beaten, punished, taken advantage of, manipulated, neglected, or deceived without the intervention of any witness, then their integrity will be lastingly impaired.
- The normal reactions to such injury should be anger and pain. Since children in this hurtful kind of environment are forbidden to express their anger, however, and since it would be unbearable to experience their pain all alone, they are compelled to suppress their feelings, repress all memory of the trauma, and idealize those guilty of the abuse. Later they will have no memory of what was done to them.
- Disassociated from the original cause, their feelings of anger, helplessness, despair, longing, anxiety, and pain will find expression in destructive acts against others (criminal behavior, mass murder) or against themselves (drug addiction, alcoholism, prostitution, psychic disorders, suicide).
- If these people become parents, they will then often direct acts of revenge for their mistreatment in childhood against their own children, whom they use as scapegoats. Child abuse is still sanctioned – indeed, held in high regard – in our society as long as it is defined as child-rearing. It is a tragic fact that parents beat their children in order to escape the emotions stemming from how they were treated by their own parents.
- If mistreated children are not to become criminals or mentally ill, it is essential that at least once in their life they come in contact with a person who knows without any doubt that the environment, not the helpless, battered child, is at fault. In this regard, knowledge or ignorance on the part of society can be instrumental in either saving or destroying a life. Here lies the great opportunity for relatives, social workers, therapists, teachers, doctors, psychiatrists, officials, and nurses to support the child and to believe her or him.
- Till now, society has protected the adult and blamed the victim. It has been abetted in its blindness by theories, still in keeping with the pedagogical principles of our great-grandparents, according to which children are viewed as crafty creatures, dominated by wicked drives, who invent stories and attack their innocent parents or desire them sexually. In reality, children tend to blame themselves for their parents’ cruelty and to absolve the parents, whom they invariably love, of all responsibility.
- For some years now, it has been possible to prove, through new therapeutic methods, that repressed traumatic experiences of childhood are stored up in the body and, though unconscious, exert an influence even in adulthood. In addition, electronic testing of the fetus has revealed a fact previously unknown to most adults-that a child responds to and learns both tenderness and cruelty from the very beginning.
- In the light of this new knowledge, even the most absurd behavior reveals its formerly hidden logic once the traumatic experiences of childhood need no longer remain shrouded in darkness.
- Our sensitization to the cruelty with which children are treated, until now commonly denied, and to the consequences of such treatment will as a matter of course bring to an end the perpetuation of violence from generation to generation.
- People whose integrity has not been damaged in childhood, who were protected, respected, and treated with honesty by their parents, will be – both in their youth and in adulthood – intelligent, responsive, empathic, and highly sensitive. They will take pleasure in life and will not feel any need to kill or even hurt others or themselves. They will use their power to defend themselves, not to attack others. They will not be able to do otherwise than respect and protect those weaker than themselves, including their children, because this is what they have learned from their own experience, and because it is this knowledge (and not the experience of cruelty) that has been stored up inside them from the beginning. It will be inconceivable to such people that earlier generations had to build up a gigantic war industry in order to feel comfortable and safe in this world. Since it will not be their unconscious drive in life to ward off intimidation experienced at a very early age, they will be able to deal with attempts at intimidation in their adult life more rationally and more creatively.
Friday, December 13, 2019
dissolving boundaries
excerpts from the story of the lost child by elena ferrante
she used that term: dissolving boundaries. it was on that occasion that she resorted to it for the first time; she struggled to elucidate the meaning, she wanted me to understand what the dissolution of boundaries meant and how much it frightened her. she was still holding my hand tight, breathing hard. she said that the outlines of things and people were delicate, that they broke like cotton thread. she whispered that for her it had always been that way, an object lost its edges and poured into another, into a solution of heterogenous materials, a merging and mixing. she exclaimed that she had always had to struggle to believe that life had firm boundaries, for she had known since she was a child that it was not like that -- it was absolutely not like that -- and so she couldn't trust in their resistance to being banged and bumped. contrary to what she had been doing, she began to utter a profusion of overexcited sentences, sometimes kneading in the vocabulary of the dialect, sometimes drawing on the vast reading she had done as a girl. she muttered that she mustn't ever be distracted: if she became distracted real things, which, with their violent, painful contortions, terrified her, would gain the upper hand over the unreal ones, which, with their physical and moral solidity, pacified her; she would be plunged into a sticky, jumbled reality and would never again be able to give sensations clear outlines. a tactile emotion would melt into a visual one, a visual one would melt into an olfactory one, ah, what is the real world, lenu, nothing, nothing, nothing about which one can say conclusively: it's like that. and so if she didn't stay alert, if she didn't pay attention to the boundaries, the waters would break through, a flood would rise, carrying everything off in clots of menstrual blood, in cancerous polyps, in bits of yellowish fiber.
* * *
i lived, in other words, on the money that pietro contributed punctually every month and that nino supplemented by taking on the rent for the house, the bills, and, i have to admit, often giving me money for clothes for myself and the children. but as long as i had had to confront all the upheavals and inconveniences and sufferings that followed my return to naples, it had seemed fair. now instead -- after that evening -- i decided that it was urgent to become as autonomous as possible. i had to write and publish regularly, i had to reinforce my profile as an author, i had to earn money. and the reason was not any literary vocation, the reason had to do with the future: did i really think that nino would take care of me and my daughters forever?
it was then that a part of me -- only a part -- began to emerge that consciously, without particular suffering, admitted that it couldn't really count on him. it wasn't just the old fear that he would leave me; rather it seemed to me an abrupt contraction of perspective. i stopped looking into the distance, i began to think that in the immediate future i couldn't expect from nino more than what he was giving me, and that i had to decide if it was enough.
* * *
. . .sometimes i obey money, sometimes respect, in some cases myself. as for infidelities, he said, if you don't find out about them at the right moment they're of no use: when you're in love you forgive everything. for infidelities to have their real impact some lovelessness has to develop first. and he went on like that, piling up painful remarks about the blindness of people in love.
* * * * * * *
she had often express that idea of eliminating herself, but, starting in the late nineties -- and especially from 2000 on -- it became a sort of teasing chorus. it was a metaphor, of course. she liked it, she had resorted to it in the most diverse circumstances, and it never occurred to me, in the many years of our friendship -- not even in the most terrible moments following tina's disappearance -- that she would think of suicide. eliminating herself was a sort of aesthetic project. one can't go on anymore, she said, electronics seems so clean and yet it dirties, dirties tremendously, and it obliges you to leave traces of yourself everywhere as if you were shitting and peeing on yourself continuously: i want to leave nothing, my favorite key is the one that deletes.
that learning had been more true in some periods, in others less. i remember a malicious tirade that started with my fame. eh, she said once, what a fuss for a name: famous or not, it's only a ribbon tied around a sack randomly filled with blood, flesh, words, shit, and petty thoughts. she mocked me at length on that point: i untie the ribbon - elena greco - and the sack stays there, it functions just the same, haphazardly, of course, without virtues or vices, until it breaks. on her darkest days she said with a bitter laugh: i want to untie my name, slip it off me, throw it away, forget it. but on other occasions she was more relaxed. it happened - let's say - that i called her hoping to persuade her to talk to me about her text and, although she forcefully denied its existence, continuing to be evasive, it sounded as if my phone call had surprised her in the middle of a creative moment. one evening i found her happily dazed. she made the usual speech about annihilating all hierarchies - so much fuss about the greatness of this one and that one, but what virtue is there in being born with certain qualities, it's like admiring the bingo basket when you shake it and good numbers come out - but she expressed herself with imagination and with precision, i perceived the pleasure of inventing images. ah, how she could use words when she wanted to. she seemed to safeguard a secret meaning that took meaning away from everything else. perhaps it was that which began to sadden me.
she used that term: dissolving boundaries. it was on that occasion that she resorted to it for the first time; she struggled to elucidate the meaning, she wanted me to understand what the dissolution of boundaries meant and how much it frightened her. she was still holding my hand tight, breathing hard. she said that the outlines of things and people were delicate, that they broke like cotton thread. she whispered that for her it had always been that way, an object lost its edges and poured into another, into a solution of heterogenous materials, a merging and mixing. she exclaimed that she had always had to struggle to believe that life had firm boundaries, for she had known since she was a child that it was not like that -- it was absolutely not like that -- and so she couldn't trust in their resistance to being banged and bumped. contrary to what she had been doing, she began to utter a profusion of overexcited sentences, sometimes kneading in the vocabulary of the dialect, sometimes drawing on the vast reading she had done as a girl. she muttered that she mustn't ever be distracted: if she became distracted real things, which, with their violent, painful contortions, terrified her, would gain the upper hand over the unreal ones, which, with their physical and moral solidity, pacified her; she would be plunged into a sticky, jumbled reality and would never again be able to give sensations clear outlines. a tactile emotion would melt into a visual one, a visual one would melt into an olfactory one, ah, what is the real world, lenu, nothing, nothing, nothing about which one can say conclusively: it's like that. and so if she didn't stay alert, if she didn't pay attention to the boundaries, the waters would break through, a flood would rise, carrying everything off in clots of menstrual blood, in cancerous polyps, in bits of yellowish fiber.
* * *
i lived, in other words, on the money that pietro contributed punctually every month and that nino supplemented by taking on the rent for the house, the bills, and, i have to admit, often giving me money for clothes for myself and the children. but as long as i had had to confront all the upheavals and inconveniences and sufferings that followed my return to naples, it had seemed fair. now instead -- after that evening -- i decided that it was urgent to become as autonomous as possible. i had to write and publish regularly, i had to reinforce my profile as an author, i had to earn money. and the reason was not any literary vocation, the reason had to do with the future: did i really think that nino would take care of me and my daughters forever?
it was then that a part of me -- only a part -- began to emerge that consciously, without particular suffering, admitted that it couldn't really count on him. it wasn't just the old fear that he would leave me; rather it seemed to me an abrupt contraction of perspective. i stopped looking into the distance, i began to think that in the immediate future i couldn't expect from nino more than what he was giving me, and that i had to decide if it was enough.
* * *
. . .sometimes i obey money, sometimes respect, in some cases myself. as for infidelities, he said, if you don't find out about them at the right moment they're of no use: when you're in love you forgive everything. for infidelities to have their real impact some lovelessness has to develop first. and he went on like that, piling up painful remarks about the blindness of people in love.
* * * * * * *
she had often express that idea of eliminating herself, but, starting in the late nineties -- and especially from 2000 on -- it became a sort of teasing chorus. it was a metaphor, of course. she liked it, she had resorted to it in the most diverse circumstances, and it never occurred to me, in the many years of our friendship -- not even in the most terrible moments following tina's disappearance -- that she would think of suicide. eliminating herself was a sort of aesthetic project. one can't go on anymore, she said, electronics seems so clean and yet it dirties, dirties tremendously, and it obliges you to leave traces of yourself everywhere as if you were shitting and peeing on yourself continuously: i want to leave nothing, my favorite key is the one that deletes.
that learning had been more true in some periods, in others less. i remember a malicious tirade that started with my fame. eh, she said once, what a fuss for a name: famous or not, it's only a ribbon tied around a sack randomly filled with blood, flesh, words, shit, and petty thoughts. she mocked me at length on that point: i untie the ribbon - elena greco - and the sack stays there, it functions just the same, haphazardly, of course, without virtues or vices, until it breaks. on her darkest days she said with a bitter laugh: i want to untie my name, slip it off me, throw it away, forget it. but on other occasions she was more relaxed. it happened - let's say - that i called her hoping to persuade her to talk to me about her text and, although she forcefully denied its existence, continuing to be evasive, it sounded as if my phone call had surprised her in the middle of a creative moment. one evening i found her happily dazed. she made the usual speech about annihilating all hierarchies - so much fuss about the greatness of this one and that one, but what virtue is there in being born with certain qualities, it's like admiring the bingo basket when you shake it and good numbers come out - but she expressed herself with imagination and with precision, i perceived the pleasure of inventing images. ah, how she could use words when she wanted to. she seemed to safeguard a secret meaning that took meaning away from everything else. perhaps it was that which began to sadden me.
Thursday, December 12, 2019
will / desire
from willful subjects by sara ahmed
"when the will becomes will power, then the fate of the subject becomes 'in its power.' and when social problems are narrated as problems of will, they become a consequence of the failure of individuals to will themselves out of situations in which they find themselves."
"given that the will becomes a technique, a way of holding a subject to account, it could be understood as a straightening device. . . a queer history of will might foreground the association between will and error and explore its myriad forms."
"the will is thus called upon to resolve the problem of the will: not being fully determined from without becomes the requirement to determine from within."
"not philosophy is practiced by those who are not philosophers and aims to create room within philosophy for others who are not philosophers. not being a philosopher working with philosophy can be understood as generative: the incapacity to return texts to their proper histories allows us to read sideways or across, thus creating a different angle on what is being reproduced. not philosophy aims not to reproduce the body of philosophy by a willful citational practice: if philosophers are cited (and in this book many philosophers are cited0 they are not only cited alongside those who are not philosophers but are not given any priority over those who are not."
"one of my key aims is to explore how the will becomes a question of time by thinking through how will relates to the past as well as the future, and how the will is thus never quite present or in the time we are in"
"when the will becomes will power, then the fate of the subject becomes 'in its power.' and when social problems are narrated as problems of will, they become a consequence of the failure of individuals to will themselves out of situations in which they find themselves."
"given that the will becomes a technique, a way of holding a subject to account, it could be understood as a straightening device. . . a queer history of will might foreground the association between will and error and explore its myriad forms."
"the will is thus called upon to resolve the problem of the will: not being fully determined from without becomes the requirement to determine from within."
"not philosophy is practiced by those who are not philosophers and aims to create room within philosophy for others who are not philosophers. not being a philosopher working with philosophy can be understood as generative: the incapacity to return texts to their proper histories allows us to read sideways or across, thus creating a different angle on what is being reproduced. not philosophy aims not to reproduce the body of philosophy by a willful citational practice: if philosophers are cited (and in this book many philosophers are cited0 they are not only cited alongside those who are not philosophers but are not given any priority over those who are not."
"one of my key aims is to explore how the will becomes a question of time by thinking through how will relates to the past as well as the future, and how the will is thus never quite present or in the time we are in"
Wednesday, December 11, 2019
unreasonable
from mathilda by mary shelley
"but woodville's words had magic in them, when beginning with the sweetest pity, he would raise me by degrees out of myself and my sorrows until i wondered at my own selfishness: but he left me and despair returned; the work of consolation was ever to begin anew. i often desired his entire absence; for i found that i was grown out of the ways of life and that by long seclusion, although i could support my accustomed grief, and drink the bitter daily draught with some degree of patience, yet i had become unfit for the slightest novelty of feeling. expectation, and hopes, and affection were all too much for me. i knew this, but at other times i was unreasonable and laid the blame upon him, who was most blameless, and peevishly thought that if his gentle soul were more gentle, if his intense sympathy were more intense, he could drive the fiend from my soul and make me more human."
"but woodville's words had magic in them, when beginning with the sweetest pity, he would raise me by degrees out of myself and my sorrows until i wondered at my own selfishness: but he left me and despair returned; the work of consolation was ever to begin anew. i often desired his entire absence; for i found that i was grown out of the ways of life and that by long seclusion, although i could support my accustomed grief, and drink the bitter daily draught with some degree of patience, yet i had become unfit for the slightest novelty of feeling. expectation, and hopes, and affection were all too much for me. i knew this, but at other times i was unreasonable and laid the blame upon him, who was most blameless, and peevishly thought that if his gentle soul were more gentle, if his intense sympathy were more intense, he could drive the fiend from my soul and make me more human."
Tuesday, December 10, 2019
a kind of flight
from there there by tommy orange
"you know what's funny? i'm all, like, street and shit in real life. but online i don't talk like that, like i am now, so it feels weird to. online i try to sound smarter than i am. i mean i choose what i type carefully, cuz that's all people know about me. what i type, what i post. it's pretty weird on there. here. the way you don't know who people are. you just get their avatar names. some profile picture. but if you post cool shit, say cool shit, people like you. did i tell you about the community i got into? the name of the place, the online community is: vunderkode. it's fucking norwegian. you probably don't know what code is. i got way into it after you died. i didn't feel like going out or going to school or nothing.
when you spend enough time online, if you're looking, you can find some cool shit. i don't see it as that much different from what you did. figuring out a way around a big fucking bully system that only gives those that came from money or power the means to make it."
"'do you know how many indian women go missing every year? geraldine says.
'do you?' i say.
'no, but i heard a high number once and the real number's probably even higher.'
'i saw something too, someone posted about women up in canada.'
'it's not just canada, it's all over. there's a secret war on women going on in the world. secret even to us. secret even though we know it,' geraldine says. she rolls down her window and lights a smoke. i light one too.
'every single place we get stuck out on the road,' she says. 'they take us, then leave us out here, leave us to dim to bone, then get all the way forgotten.' she flicks her cigarette out the window. she only likes a cigarette for the first few drags.
'i always think of the men who do that kinda thing like, i know they're out there somewhere --'
'and paul,' she says.
'you know what he's going through. he's not who we're talking about.'
'you're not wrong. but the difference between the men doing it and your average violent drunk is not as big as you think. then you've got the sick pigs in high places who pay for our bodies on the black market with bitcoin, someone way up at the top who gets off on listening to the recorded screams of women like us being ripped apart, knocked against the cement floors in hidden rooms --'
'jesus,' i say.
'what? you don't think it's real? the people who run this shit are real-life monsters. the people you never see. what they want is more and more, and when that isn't enough, they want what can't be gotten easily, the recorded screams of dying indian women, maybe even a taxidermied torso, a collection of indian women's heads, there's probably some floating in tanks with blue lights behind them in a secret office on the top floor of an office building in midtown manhattan.'
'you've given this some thought,' i say.
'i meet with a lotta women,' she says. 'trapped by violence. they have kids to think about. they can't just leave, with the kids, no money, no relatives. i have to talk to these women about options. i have to talk them into going to shelters. i have to hear about when the men accidentally go too far. so no, i'm not telling you that you should go back. i'm taking you to the bus station. but i'm saying you shouldn't be out here on the side of the highway at night. i'm saying you should have texted me, asked me for a ride.'"
"your dad hardly ever talked about any of it, being indian or growing up on the rez, or even what he felt like now that he's a certifiable urban indian. except sometimes. when he felt like it. out of nowhere.
you'd be riding in his red ford truck to blockbuster to rent a movie. you'd be listening to your dad's peyote tapes. the tape-staticky gourd-rattle and kettle-drum boom. he liked to play it loud. you couldn't stand how noticeable the sound was. how noticeably indian your dad was. you'd ask if you could turn it off. you'd make him turn off his tapes. you'd put on 106 kmel - rap or r&b. but then he'd try to dance to that. he'd stick his big indian lips out to embarrass you, stick one flat hand out and stab at the air in rhythm just to mess with you. that's when you'd turn the music off altogether. and that was when you might hear a story from your dad about his childhood. about how he used to pick cotton with his grandparents for a dime a day or the time an owl threw rocks at him and his friends from a tree or the time his great-grandma split a tornado in two with a prayer.
the chip you carry has to do with being born and raised in oakland. a concrete chip, a slab really, heavy on one side, the half side, the side not white. as for your mom's side, as for your whiteness, there's too much and not enough there to know what to do with. you're from a people who took and took and took and took. and from a people taken. you were both and neither. when you took baths, you'd stare at your brown arms against your white legs in the water and wonder what they were doing together on the same body, in the same bathtub. . .
your dad was the kind of drunk who disappears weekends, lands himself in jail. he was the kind of drunk who had to stop completely. who wouldn't have a drop. so you had it coming in a way. that need that won't quit. that years-deep pit you were bound to dig, crawl into, struggle to get out of. your parents maybe burned a too-deep, too-wide god hole through you. the hole was unfillable.
coming out of your twenties you started to drink every night. there were many reasons for this. but you did it without a thought. most addictions aren't premeditated. you slept better. drinking felt good."
"'now you young men in here, listen up. don't get too excited out there. that dance is your prayer. so don't rush it, and don't dance how you practice. there's only one way for an indian man to express himself. it's that dance that comes from all the way back there. all the way over there. you learn that dance to keep it, to use it. whatever you got going on in your life, you don't leave it all in here, like them players do when they go out on that field, you bring it with you, you dance it. any other way you try to say what you really mean, it's just gonna make you cry. don't act like you don't cry. that's what we do. indian men. we're crybabies. you know it. but not out there,' he says, and points to the door of the locker room.
a couple of the older guys make this low huh sound, then another couple of guys say aho in unison. orvil looks around the room, and he sees all these men dressed up like him. they all needed to dress up to look indian too. there's something like the shaking of feathers he felt somewhere between his heart and his stomach. he knows what the guy said is true. to cry is to waste the feeling. he needs to dance with it. crying is for when there's nothing else left to do. this is a good day, this is a good feeling, something he needs, to dance the way he needs to dance to win the prize. but no. not the money. to dance for the first time like he learned, from the screen but also from practice. from the dancing came the dancing.
there are hundreds of dancers in front of him. behind him. to his left and right. he's surrounded by the variegation of color and pattern specific to indianness, gradients from one color to the next, geometrically sequenced sequined shapes on shiny and leathered fabrics, the quill, bead, ribbon, plume, feathers from magpies, hawks, crows, eagles. there are crowns and gourds and bells and drumsticks, metal cones, sticked and arrowed flickers, shag anklets, and hairpipe bandoliers, barrettes and bracelets, and bustles that fan out in perfect circles. he watches people point out each other's regalia. he is an old station wagon at a car show. he is a fraud. he tries to shake off the feeling of feeling like a fraud. he can't allow himself to feel like a fraud because then he'll probably act like one. to get to that feeling, to get to that prayer, you have to trick yourself out of thinking altogether. out of acting. out of everything. to dance as if time only mattered insofar as you could keep a beat to it, in order to dance in such a way that time itself discontinued, disappeared, ran out, or into the feeling of nothingness under your feet when you jumped, when you dipped your shoulders like you were trying to dodge the very air you were suspended in, your feathers a flutter of echoes centuries old, your whole being a kind of flight."
"you know what's funny? i'm all, like, street and shit in real life. but online i don't talk like that, like i am now, so it feels weird to. online i try to sound smarter than i am. i mean i choose what i type carefully, cuz that's all people know about me. what i type, what i post. it's pretty weird on there. here. the way you don't know who people are. you just get their avatar names. some profile picture. but if you post cool shit, say cool shit, people like you. did i tell you about the community i got into? the name of the place, the online community is: vunderkode. it's fucking norwegian. you probably don't know what code is. i got way into it after you died. i didn't feel like going out or going to school or nothing.
when you spend enough time online, if you're looking, you can find some cool shit. i don't see it as that much different from what you did. figuring out a way around a big fucking bully system that only gives those that came from money or power the means to make it."
"'do you know how many indian women go missing every year? geraldine says.
'do you?' i say.
'no, but i heard a high number once and the real number's probably even higher.'
'i saw something too, someone posted about women up in canada.'
'it's not just canada, it's all over. there's a secret war on women going on in the world. secret even to us. secret even though we know it,' geraldine says. she rolls down her window and lights a smoke. i light one too.
'every single place we get stuck out on the road,' she says. 'they take us, then leave us out here, leave us to dim to bone, then get all the way forgotten.' she flicks her cigarette out the window. she only likes a cigarette for the first few drags.
'i always think of the men who do that kinda thing like, i know they're out there somewhere --'
'and paul,' she says.
'you know what he's going through. he's not who we're talking about.'
'you're not wrong. but the difference between the men doing it and your average violent drunk is not as big as you think. then you've got the sick pigs in high places who pay for our bodies on the black market with bitcoin, someone way up at the top who gets off on listening to the recorded screams of women like us being ripped apart, knocked against the cement floors in hidden rooms --'
'jesus,' i say.
'what? you don't think it's real? the people who run this shit are real-life monsters. the people you never see. what they want is more and more, and when that isn't enough, they want what can't be gotten easily, the recorded screams of dying indian women, maybe even a taxidermied torso, a collection of indian women's heads, there's probably some floating in tanks with blue lights behind them in a secret office on the top floor of an office building in midtown manhattan.'
'you've given this some thought,' i say.
'i meet with a lotta women,' she says. 'trapped by violence. they have kids to think about. they can't just leave, with the kids, no money, no relatives. i have to talk to these women about options. i have to talk them into going to shelters. i have to hear about when the men accidentally go too far. so no, i'm not telling you that you should go back. i'm taking you to the bus station. but i'm saying you shouldn't be out here on the side of the highway at night. i'm saying you should have texted me, asked me for a ride.'"
"your dad hardly ever talked about any of it, being indian or growing up on the rez, or even what he felt like now that he's a certifiable urban indian. except sometimes. when he felt like it. out of nowhere.
you'd be riding in his red ford truck to blockbuster to rent a movie. you'd be listening to your dad's peyote tapes. the tape-staticky gourd-rattle and kettle-drum boom. he liked to play it loud. you couldn't stand how noticeable the sound was. how noticeably indian your dad was. you'd ask if you could turn it off. you'd make him turn off his tapes. you'd put on 106 kmel - rap or r&b. but then he'd try to dance to that. he'd stick his big indian lips out to embarrass you, stick one flat hand out and stab at the air in rhythm just to mess with you. that's when you'd turn the music off altogether. and that was when you might hear a story from your dad about his childhood. about how he used to pick cotton with his grandparents for a dime a day or the time an owl threw rocks at him and his friends from a tree or the time his great-grandma split a tornado in two with a prayer.
the chip you carry has to do with being born and raised in oakland. a concrete chip, a slab really, heavy on one side, the half side, the side not white. as for your mom's side, as for your whiteness, there's too much and not enough there to know what to do with. you're from a people who took and took and took and took. and from a people taken. you were both and neither. when you took baths, you'd stare at your brown arms against your white legs in the water and wonder what they were doing together on the same body, in the same bathtub. . .
your dad was the kind of drunk who disappears weekends, lands himself in jail. he was the kind of drunk who had to stop completely. who wouldn't have a drop. so you had it coming in a way. that need that won't quit. that years-deep pit you were bound to dig, crawl into, struggle to get out of. your parents maybe burned a too-deep, too-wide god hole through you. the hole was unfillable.
coming out of your twenties you started to drink every night. there were many reasons for this. but you did it without a thought. most addictions aren't premeditated. you slept better. drinking felt good."
"'now you young men in here, listen up. don't get too excited out there. that dance is your prayer. so don't rush it, and don't dance how you practice. there's only one way for an indian man to express himself. it's that dance that comes from all the way back there. all the way over there. you learn that dance to keep it, to use it. whatever you got going on in your life, you don't leave it all in here, like them players do when they go out on that field, you bring it with you, you dance it. any other way you try to say what you really mean, it's just gonna make you cry. don't act like you don't cry. that's what we do. indian men. we're crybabies. you know it. but not out there,' he says, and points to the door of the locker room.
a couple of the older guys make this low huh sound, then another couple of guys say aho in unison. orvil looks around the room, and he sees all these men dressed up like him. they all needed to dress up to look indian too. there's something like the shaking of feathers he felt somewhere between his heart and his stomach. he knows what the guy said is true. to cry is to waste the feeling. he needs to dance with it. crying is for when there's nothing else left to do. this is a good day, this is a good feeling, something he needs, to dance the way he needs to dance to win the prize. but no. not the money. to dance for the first time like he learned, from the screen but also from practice. from the dancing came the dancing.
there are hundreds of dancers in front of him. behind him. to his left and right. he's surrounded by the variegation of color and pattern specific to indianness, gradients from one color to the next, geometrically sequenced sequined shapes on shiny and leathered fabrics, the quill, bead, ribbon, plume, feathers from magpies, hawks, crows, eagles. there are crowns and gourds and bells and drumsticks, metal cones, sticked and arrowed flickers, shag anklets, and hairpipe bandoliers, barrettes and bracelets, and bustles that fan out in perfect circles. he watches people point out each other's regalia. he is an old station wagon at a car show. he is a fraud. he tries to shake off the feeling of feeling like a fraud. he can't allow himself to feel like a fraud because then he'll probably act like one. to get to that feeling, to get to that prayer, you have to trick yourself out of thinking altogether. out of acting. out of everything. to dance as if time only mattered insofar as you could keep a beat to it, in order to dance in such a way that time itself discontinued, disappeared, ran out, or into the feeling of nothingness under your feet when you jumped, when you dipped your shoulders like you were trying to dodge the very air you were suspended in, your feathers a flutter of echoes centuries old, your whole being a kind of flight."
Monday, December 9, 2019
honey
from the proof of the honey by salwa al neimi
"the desire for knowledge fuels my desire for men. no, my desire for men fuels my desire for knowledge. to learn, by myself, about desire and pleasure, to learn about others, and about the world. after the thinker, i began to judge every new man in my life based on his pedagogical qualities above all. the more a man teaches me, the more i love him. after the thinker, i could no longer put up with a man who couldn't teach me.
for me, the pleasure of learning went along with the pleasure of sex. the center of pleasure and the center of knowledge got mixed up with each other in my head and fused together inseparably. my sexual curiosity grew deeper, deep as an abyss: those who cross my path cannot help but fall into it."
"the desire for knowledge fuels my desire for men. no, my desire for men fuels my desire for knowledge. to learn, by myself, about desire and pleasure, to learn about others, and about the world. after the thinker, i began to judge every new man in my life based on his pedagogical qualities above all. the more a man teaches me, the more i love him. after the thinker, i could no longer put up with a man who couldn't teach me.
for me, the pleasure of learning went along with the pleasure of sex. the center of pleasure and the center of knowledge got mixed up with each other in my head and fused together inseparably. my sexual curiosity grew deeper, deep as an abyss: those who cross my path cannot help but fall into it."
Sunday, December 8, 2019
eighteen days until christmas
by maggie nelson, from shiner
i lost the romance of this place
and woke up old. one darling
fantasy shattered over the next,
folding over a fist drenched
in my hip. the christmas trees
are bound and stacked up
outside, the air can't decide
what to make of itself, and we
are about to throw a president
out. you are not your mother,
and each of your dead lives on
in you and smells like the moon.
large and mosquito-like,
my prose clatters off
my fingers. i woke up old
and into happy uncertainty,
the vitamins i feed to the streets,
the real relations within a bead.
oh pouring cylinder, stark
uncertainty, racket of leaves
helicoptering to their death--
my love is coming out
over and over again.
here it is, what
i always wanted. the air
spills ash; i suppose
it is light.
i lost the romance of this place
and woke up old. one darling
fantasy shattered over the next,
folding over a fist drenched
in my hip. the christmas trees
are bound and stacked up
outside, the air can't decide
what to make of itself, and we
are about to throw a president
out. you are not your mother,
and each of your dead lives on
in you and smells like the moon.
large and mosquito-like,
my prose clatters off
my fingers. i woke up old
and into happy uncertainty,
the vitamins i feed to the streets,
the real relations within a bead.
oh pouring cylinder, stark
uncertainty, racket of leaves
helicoptering to their death--
my love is coming out
over and over again.
here it is, what
i always wanted. the air
spills ash; i suppose
it is light.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)